Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Tero:
Lend-lease was the birth of the military industrial complex ?



>"Much of the aid, valued at more than 49.1 billion dollars, amounted to outright gifts.

What was the value of those WWI destroyers the Amis "gave" to the RN ? Are such "clearing the stocks, everything must go - sale" - type obsolete equipment hand outs "outright gifts" included in that 49,1 billion figure ? What was the value of the "proper" lend-lease billables ? What is the ratios of these values ?

Boy, I just love tearing these ensyclopedia simplifications to shreads :-)

>Some of the cost of the lend-lease program was offset by so-called reverse leand lease, under which allied nations gave US troops stationed abroad about $8 billion worth of aid.

How was that calculated ? What is included in the costs, what is left out ? For example, the UK air bases: is the "rent" on the land, buildings (and the cost of contructing them), utilities etc. included ? Any collateral, "hidden" costs attributable to the upkeep of these bases such as construction of power stations to produce the electricity they needed ?

>And you will note in a message above that about 2/3 of aid to the USSR was not collected.

So ?

>Britian and the Commonwealth received the largest share at 63% (much in expensive ships like the 50 destroyers in 1940, aircraft carriers, and cargo vessels).

I believe those 50 destroyers were the 4 stack WWI surpluss earmarked for scratching.

>The USSR received 22%. China was third in aid. Britian also repaid in bases, such as a 99 year lease on a base in the Azores for the 50 destroyers.

That British "lease" is addressed elsewhere :-)

>Noted above, about 2/3 of Soviet aid was written off. And no interest collected?

No interest, yes. Any notable benefits collected instead ?

>The US's industry boom in the 50's was not because the US sucked Britian and France dry during the war, the war sucked them dry.

More like they lost their "free" supply of raw materials and resources when they had to let go of the majority of their overseas colonies. The US had created a network of "banana repubic" trade arrangements that ensured influx of raw materials and exports of goods at favourable costs and prices.

>Much of the intial cost for lend lease was born by the US Government, not direct payments by China, for example, to Ford or Boeing.

Yes. But which was more beneficial to the manufacturers: direct payment or government IOU's that quaranteed lucrative deals when government acquisitions were planned.

Why did Eisenhower fear the military industrial complex so much that he felt the need to warn about them ? And why was that warning silenced to oblivion ? Why have the dots not been connected ?

>All that material does not equate to blood and lives and tears, though it did mean a lot less Soviet Blood and a lot more Axis Blood shed.

Arguably, yes.

Tue Jul 11 11:05:07 2000


 Max Russia is still paying on its WW2 debts!!!!!  (Jul, 5)
 Stephen re: Russia is still paying on its WW2 debts!!!!!  (Jul, 6)
 Karl Brandel re: Russia is still paying on its WW2 debts!!!!!  (Jul, 6)
Bob Potter re: Russia is still paying on its WW2 debts!!!!!  (Jul, 6)
 Stephen re: Finland? (Jul, 6)
Scott Schaffer re: Finland? (Jul, 6)
Andreas Larka re: Finland? (Jul, 6)
Tero Concur. AFAIR Finland received/requested no Marshall aid  (-) (Jul, 6)
Tapani Kossila re: Concur. AFAIR Finland received/requested no Marshall aid  (Jul, 6)
 Tero Possible answer (Jul, 6)
Bob Potter re: Possible answer (Jul, 7)
Tero re: Possible answer (Jul, 7)
 Arashekino re: Russia is still paying on its WW2 debts!!!!!  (Jul, 6)
Karl Brandel re: Russia is still paying on its WW2 debts!!!!!  (Jul, 6)
Bob Potter re: Russia is still paying on its WW2 debts!!!!!  (Jul, 7)
 Max Who benefited most from the lend-lease? (Jul, 7)
Tero Semantics (Jul, 7)
 Stephen re: Actually... (Jul, 8)
 Miguel Morao Azores base (Jul, 10)
 Stephen re: Azores base (Jul, 11)
Scott Fraser Two bases for 180 aircraft � not a bad deal in 1940! (Jul, 15)
  • Tero Lend-lease was the birth of the military industrial complex ? (Jul, 11)
     Arashekino re: I wish I could write so well! (-) (Jul, 12)
     Stephen re: The Cold War and Soviet imperialism was the birth of the ... (Jul, 15)
     Arashekino re: You asked for it! (Jul, 15)
  • Records: 25

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.