Arashekino:
re: I am not enjoying this!
You win basically, I liked your replies. My ship has been sunk. I still question the interpretation of the reception recieved by the Germans. I question wether Stalin should recieve the full blame. I question wether Stalin is the terrible man he is made out to be. All this requires a lifetime of research and I am not up to it so we'll just let the guilty verdict stand.
A few final notes, you still don't seem to understand what I am saying about the difficulties of multi-ethnic armies. This problem of defection occurs or has occurred almost despite the government because ethnic minorities are always oppressed. The one place you probably won't have this problem is America because we have mostly perfected the melting pot. With the Civil rights most people feel happy, and integrated. The Soviets allowed seperate Republics for these minorities but did not allow true Autonomy. The structure they set up allowed for true freedom and independance for these nations in the long term, something ethnic minorities in the US, or Latin American countries will never have.
On the Cossacks, don't forget that these people had a privileged position in the old order, they lost with Communism, what is more they really were a tribe of profesional mercaneries. So one wonders what their true motivations were. Also you seem to confuse Kazak, Cossack, and Kalmyuk three different tribes. You know the Germans were very scared of the Kalmyuks, the quote is something like "A slant eyed mongol/Kalmyuk with a sniper rifle". I suppose they fought well on both sides, as did Cossacks, and Kazakistani's.
Finally, on moral relativism etc. In America we learned until recently that the Indians were the bad guys. Kind of makes you question everything those old historians wrote. Wow, the same generation wrote about Stalin. Hmmm.
Arashekino
Sun Jul 9 21:37:54 2000
Randy
Hitler vs The World (Jul, 5)
Mr. L. L.
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 5)
Stephen
re: Sounds about right. n/t (Jul, 6)
Mr. L. L.
re: Sounds about right. (Jul, 6)
Arashekino
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 6)
Arashekino
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 6)
Wen Jin
Good Point (Jul, 6)
Men
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 6)
Arashekino
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 7)
Scott Schaffer
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 7)
Arashekino
re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 7)
Scott Schaffer
re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 7)
Majordomo
re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 7)
Scott Schaffer
re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 8)
Arashekino
re: As to your points (Jul, 8)
Scott Schaffer
re: As to your points (Jul, 8)
Arashekino
re: I am really enjoying this! (Jul, 8)
Scott Schaffer
re: I am really enjoying this! (Jul, 9)
Arashekino
re: I am not enjoying this! (Jul, 9)
Scott Schaffer
Good debate! : ) (Jul, 10)
snuky ush
re: I am really enjoying this! (Jul, 13)
Men
re: As to your points (Jul, 12)
Arashekino
re: As to your points (Jul, 12)
HAOster
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 5)
snuky ush
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 13)