Scott Fraser:
Enlightening
Russians were taught in school that for example: Allies landed on Normandy with almost no opposition, but never taught about secret 1939 proticol with Hitler.
And here is the crux of the debate. "History is the propaganda of the victors", and we know only what we are taught. As time passes, vested interests fade and participants die, opening the door to more critical and complete examination of the events of the period.
In Canada, we are taught that D-Day was the event which decided the war. Virtually nothing is said about the war in the USSR, except that the Germans also fought there. Seriously, I had a first-year university course on twentieth century military history, taught by a retired Major in the Canadian Army, and in four months we spent two days on the Eastern Front. We spent more time on the Battle of Britain than we did on the Great Patriotic War.
There is middle ground, somewhere, where the deeds and accomplishments of all belligerents can be assessed and a more balanced verdict rendered. But first we must overcome the "I've always been told" syndrome, to look through the veil of propaganda, misinformation, selective truths, and exaggerations to get at the meat of the issue.
Soviet historiography is mocked in the West, where it is seen purely as a propaganda exercise. By way of example, take Lend-Lease. Soviet texts downplay its importance, if they mention it at all. English-language histories credit it with saving the Soviet Union from defeat, bandying about words like "decisive" and "critical". The truth lies in between these extremes � in the fighting in late 1941, the presence of British-supplied Hurricanes and Tomahawks made a difference around Leningrad and Moscow. The presence of Spitfires and Airacobras helped the VVS defeat the Luftwaffe over Kuban. The Studebaker truck was an important tool for the Red Army. The aluminum and other alloys, the metallurgic technology, the locomotives, the radios and other smaller items, ...
>>>
Sun Jul 9 05:12:14 2000
Stephen
West-Allied Bombing as Aid to Soviets? (Jul, 6)
Arashekino
re: Great dude! But this is the "Russian..... (Jul, 6)
Nick
re:Nice Propaganda! (Jul, 6)
TIM
re:Nice Propaganda! (Jul, 6)
Scott Fraser
re: "Allies" perhaps. Not partners, never friends. (Jul, 7)
clarence morgan samuels
re:Nice Propaganda! (Jul, 7)
TIM
re:Nice Propaganda! (Jul, 7)
Vlad
re:interesting??? (Jul, 8)
Samuel
re:interesting??? (Jul, 9)
Arashekino
re:Can you really get me a job with Pravda? (-) (Jul, 9)
Arashekino
re:interesting??? (Jul, 9)
- Scott Fraser
Enlightening (Jul, 9)
Arashekino
re:Nice Propaganda! (Jul, 7)
Nick
re:GPW NOT "VIRTUALLY IGNORED" (Jul, 10)
Scott Fraser
re:GPW NOT (Jul, 11)
Nick
re:GPW NOT (Jul, 11)
Scott Fraser
SIG revisionism (Jul, 12)
Max
Unknown war (Jul, 11)
Stephen
re:Nicely said Nick. (Jul, 8)
Arashekino
re:Apology for Steve (Jul, 9)
Scott Fraser
re: Some critical questions (Jul, 6)