Arashekino:
re: I am really enjoying this!
What greater challenge than to defend one who has been totally defamed. I think I shall continue.
Whole tribes and nations defecting, this has been a significant problem since multi-tribal nations were formed. Xerses, and his Persian hordes, what about Braveheart where the Irish defect from the English. See Joan of Arc, what nationality were the Burgundians? I can go on. The Aztec coalition broke apart, the Mohawks defected to the British while the Oneidas fought for the Americans. In WW II, a large number of Croations, went over, more Tunisians would have joined the Axis if the Germans were winning. How about Czechoslovakia? Sudeten Germans, Hungarians, Slovakians and Ruthenians all defected. Was this because they hated "democracy"?
Bagged that one!
Okay, Stalin himself probably killed no one. Dictators don't survive in a vaccum. It is a falsity to think everything he did was by himself. You let the Soviet people off to easily. Katyn forest, they killed Poles "Enemy troops!!!" Killing troops who "defect" who "run in the face of combat" was common practice of all militaries. Perhaps primitive but I imagine effective. Is this Stalins fault?
Your next point, the war is Stalins fault! Well perhaps it is Polands fault! After all they stabbed Czechoslovakia in the Back for a couple minor border provinces. They invaded them! Were the Poles originally axis troops?
Finally, leftists have never provided the kind of unified front that Facists and right wingers have. Study the left under any context and it is easy to see why they lost the cold war. More factions than Christianity. So of course leftists criticize Stalin. I mentioned Kruzchev, we could mention the Trotkyites.
Final question as long as we are throwing around blame. Who is responsible for all the dead in Africa through colonialism and slavery? Who is responsible for all the dead of America(Native America) can we assign blame to a system? a person? What about 9 million Koreans. You know the South Koreans danced and sang with the Northerners when they came. Does this mean that the UN, the US supported the bad guys in that war?
Also, I did not really understand your quotation on production. Your point seems to be that collective agriculture was not efficient. I don't argue with you. However, judging by all the homelessness I see in America our system is not efficent either.
Arashekino
Sat Jul 8 10:13:33 2000
Randy
Hitler vs The World (Jul, 5)
Mr. L. L.
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 5)
Stephen
re: Sounds about right. n/t (Jul, 6)
Mr. L. L.
re: Sounds about right. (Jul, 6)
Arashekino
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 6)
Arashekino
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 6)
Wen Jin
Good Point (Jul, 6)
Men
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 6)
Arashekino
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 7)
Scott Schaffer
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 7)
Arashekino
re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 7)
Scott Schaffer
re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 7)
Majordomo
re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 7)
Scott Schaffer
re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 8)
Arashekino
re: As to your points (Jul, 8)
Scott Schaffer
re: As to your points (Jul, 8)
Arashekino
re: I am really enjoying this! (Jul, 8)
Scott Schaffer
re: I am really enjoying this! (Jul, 9)
Arashekino
re: I am not enjoying this! (Jul, 9)
Scott Schaffer
Good debate! : ) (Jul, 10)
snuky ush
re: I am really enjoying this! (Jul, 13)
Men
re: As to your points (Jul, 12)
Arashekino
re: As to your points (Jul, 12)
HAOster
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 5)
snuky ush
re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 13)