Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Scott Schaffer:
re: How do I know what you are saying is true?

I know the war in the East was horrendous, probably the dirtiest war ever fought, and I'm not trying to downplay the way the Western Soviet Union was ravaged by Hitler. However, Stalin had more than his fair share of brutal atrocities as well.

Does Katyn Forest ring a bell? What about Order 227, calling for the shooting of retreating Soviet soldiers? What about the deportation of hundreds of thousands of people from the Baltic states, after the Soviets annexed them? Or the treatment of German POWs and the civilian population of Germany in the last days of the war? What about the treatment of the surviving Russians liberated from German camps, who found themselves freed from one concentration camp only to be returned to another because of their 'treason'?

I'm still new to the Eastern Front; I willingly admit that. That's why most of my posts on this board are restricted to asking questions rather than handing out answers. However, I've read enough to know that trying to classify either side as the knight in shining armor is pure and utter folly, more so than in most any other wars.

As for colloboration, no, I don't consider forced deportation as 'colloboration' (though Stalin seemed to, considering the amount of time some of those people spent in his Gulags after the war). However, these were men assigned to combat Partisans and even hold less important sectors of the front, not just labor in slave camps.

And as for armed volunteers, it depends on what you would classify as 'Soviet'. If you classify what was considered Soviet territory on June 22nd 1941, then there were significantly more than Vlasov's force. As I mentioned in replying to Arashekino, there were supposedly about 250,000 Cossacks under arms in German service.

Once again, to reiterate, this is not to apoligize for German atrocities, not in the LEAST. But I view the war in the east as a war between two criminal regimes with the Soviet people, unfortunately, caught in the crossfire. As I mentioned, I view the Soviet people of the time as victims of the war and as heroes for defeating the Nazis, but I view their leadership in the 1930's and 1940's as criminals who were almost as responsible for what their people went through as Hitler himself. This is just my own opinion (and to be honest I think it makes things easier; you don't have to apoligize for or excuse things like in the west, you can just say 'the Soviets did this' or 'the Germans did that').

Sat Jul 8 07:48:37 2000


Randy Hitler vs The World (Jul, 5)
 Mr. L. L. re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 5)
 Stephen re: Sounds about right. n/t (Jul, 6)
 Mr. L. L. re: Sounds about right. (Jul, 6)
 Arashekino re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 6)
 Arashekino re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 6)
Wen Jin Good Point (Jul, 6)
 Men re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 6)
 Arashekino re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 7)
 Scott Schaffer re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 7)
 Arashekino re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 7)
Scott Schaffer re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 7)
 Majordomo re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 7)
  • Scott Schaffer re: How do I know what you are saying is true? (Jul, 8)
  •  Arashekino re: As to your points (Jul, 8)
    Scott Schaffer re: As to your points (Jul, 8)
     Arashekino re: I am really enjoying this! (Jul, 8)
    Scott Schaffer re: I am really enjoying this! (Jul, 9)
     Arashekino re: I am not enjoying this! (Jul, 9)
     Scott Schaffer Good debate! : ) (Jul, 10)
    snuky ush re: I am really enjoying this! (Jul, 13)
     Men re: As to your points (Jul, 12)
     Arashekino re: As to your points (Jul, 12)
    HAOster re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 5)
    snuky ush re: Hitler vs The World (Jul, 13)

    Records: 25

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.