Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


AndyW:
re: Best movie on war in the East

Bob

First the critic rating COME AND SEE as No. 1 movie of 1987 is not mine, but those of a non-commercial movie organization in Germany.

Second, I also saw FMJ, and I too, rate this movie lower than COME AND SEE, maybe for myself also as #4. On the other hand I�m relatively sure that you will not like COME AND SEE, because of the fact that it is much less *right* in means of equipment, historical evidence, uniforms etc...f.ex. the face of the 12 year-old Flori turns from that of a child to that of an very old man during MONTHS. The movie is full of symbols and abstracts like this, it�s far off being a documentary or battle description.

Generally I have no problem with mistakes and even blunder in war movies as long as the plot is good. Of course the fact that a Marine in training possesses a loaded rifle that easy is somewhat wrong, but it is much more dense that Gomer Pyle (?) kills the Drill sergant and himself with a RIFLE, who became his �bride� and the �most lovable� tool earlier in the movie. If you remember, the rifle and its use (actually he was assigned to become a sniper) was the ONLY thing in what Gomer was good in. Of course it would be more �realistic� if Kubrick would have let Fowler killing his Drill Sargent and himself with a knife or so, but the RIFLE was a pretty strong symbol (remember how he �talked� to it, like to a lover? the pray: �This is my Rifle...�). The fact that �ex-Gomer,-now-killing-machine� Pyle shoots his Drill Sergant with THAT rifle is essential.

As for �STALINGRAD�: It has some good scenes: the assault on the factory, the �friendly fire� scene within the factory, the execution of civilians, and the tank assault (the scene where a group of T-34 suddenly turn right towards the hidden infantry, after almost driving by) are very dense. On the other hand, I think the movie wanted to tell too much: The �love�-scene, the comic-like, always bad and omnipresent Nazi Officer, soldiers singing during cease-fire � not only annoying, but also taken from other movies. But anyway, still one of the better war movies in an ocean of mediocre.

THE CROSS OF IRON: The bad things: Bruce Coburn was a miscast. Giving them soldiers a �human touch� of letting them take care about that young Russian soldier boy is Hollywood (anyway good enough for STALINGRAD to repeat it!). The love scene is again annoying, although the surrealistic scene in the hospital is quite good. What keeps in my mind is the intro (the German children lullaby in this coherence �great!), the scene with the gay orderly officer (taboo!) and Klaus Loewitsch�s and Maximilain Schell�s acting performance � that�s it. But, a very �modern� film for the 70-ies, but KEEP AWAY FROM THE SEQUEL!!!

Thu Jul 6 16:47:03 2000


 AndyW Best movie on war in the East (Jul, 4)
Bob Potter re: Best movie on war in the East (Jul, 5)
Andreas Larka re: Best movie on war in the East (Jul, 5)
Tero THE best war movie ever (Jul, 5)
 Sami re: THE best war movie ever (Jul, 5)
snuky ush re: Best movie on war in the East (Jul, 13)
 AndyW re: Best movie on war in the East (Jul, 5)
Bob Potter re: Best movie on war in the East (Jul, 6)
  • AndyW re: Best movie on war in the East (Jul, 6)
     Majordomo To the Russian audience?  (Jul, 6)
     Jorge Visca re: To the Russian audience?  (Jul, 7)
    George W Hogg re: Best movie on war in the East (Jul, 8)
    George W Hogg re: Anybody seen the Asscent ? (Jul, 8)
  •  Juhis J re: Best movie on war in the East (Jul, 11)

    Records: 14

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.