Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Scott Fraser:
re: Some critical questions

Q: Who is John Ellis and what is his background?
Q: Who is his publisher?
Q: Are his observations supported by footnotes listing sources for his conclusions?

RE his "points":

1.) There is no doubt that the destruction of German cities put enormous stress on the civilian population. However, I suubmit that recontruction work was performed by POWs and civilians unfit for military service. How many men, aged 17-30, were not drafted because they were needed to clear rubble?

2.) Not true. Several Jagdgruppen remained in Italy until 1944, when air defense there was given over to the ANR-RSI. Most of JG54, all of JG 5, JG 51, JG 52, JG 53, and other Gruppen remained in Russia throughout 1943, and in some cases right up to the end of the war. Do you believe there were no Luftwaffe fighters at Kursk in July 1943?

3.) Galland's report may sound ominous, but the major concern for the Luftwaffe would be pilots. In April 1944 German aircraft production was about 3400 aircraft, of which 1800 were single-engined fighters. This (monthly) production rate rose sharply later on in 1944.

4.) What proportion were Luftwaffe Flak units compared to Wehrmacht infantry and armoured units? It was the Wehrmacht Heer which needed to be defeated, not the Luftwaffe. As for anti-aircraft guns, after the advent of the 75mm PaK 40 these were rarely used against tanks and were totally unsuitable for use as artillery. Luftwaffe commanders hated to "lend" their guns to the Wehrmacht, who stripped the special sights, shields, and other equipment rendering them no longer usable against aircraft.

5.) Which factory? What proportion of which aircraft did this factory produce in normal circumstances, and what proportion was this figure of total aircraft production?

6.) These estimates are from Speer, Inside the Third Reich p.445ff. There is no question, the destruction of Germany's oil industry had a significant impact on their ability to wage war after ...

>>> 

Thu Jul 6 15:06:23 2000


 Stephen West-Allied Bombing as Aid to Soviets? (Jul, 6)
Arashekino re: Great dude! But this is the "Russian..... (Jul, 6)
 Nick re:Nice Propaganda! (Jul, 6)
TIM re:Nice Propaganda! (Jul, 6)
Scott Fraser re: "Allies" perhaps. Not partners, never friends. (Jul, 7)
 clarence morgan samuels re:Nice Propaganda! (Jul, 7)
TIM re:Nice Propaganda! (Jul, 7)
Vlad re:interesting??? (Jul, 8)
Samuel re:interesting??? (Jul, 9)
 Arashekino re:Can you really get me a job with Pravda? (-) (Jul, 9)
Arashekino re:interesting??? (Jul, 9)
Scott Fraser Enlightening (Jul, 9)
 Arashekino re:Nice Propaganda! (Jul, 7)
 Nick re:GPW NOT "VIRTUALLY IGNORED" (Jul, 10)
Scott Fraser re:GPW NOT  (Jul, 11)
 Nick re:GPW NOT  (Jul, 11)
Scott Fraser SIG revisionism (Jul, 12)
Max Unknown war (Jul, 11)
 Stephen re:Nicely said Nick. (Jul, 8)
 Arashekino re:Apology for Steve (Jul, 9)
  • Scott Fraser re: Some critical questions (Jul, 6)
  • Records: 21

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.