Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Tero:
Revisionism is not allways bad

>More information & sources are discovered that CAN lead to a clearer picture. This is a very rough road & sometimes the picture gets distorted along the way. It's the task of historians, professional & serious amateurs alike, to search for the answers.

That is true.

>Sometimes you don't get the answer you want.

And sometimes you have the answers ready in the back of your head and you read the sources so that you reach the answers you are aiming at. That is the mortal danger in the history business.

>That's what separates the real historians from crackpot revisionists.

Who determines who is a real historian who has found some sources that warrant the revisionistic new interpretation that pulls the rug from under the "established version" and who is a crackpot reading more into the old sources than there really is ? And who is to say that the crackpot is totally wrong ? What is a better way to silence a valid interpretation totally contradicting the "established version" than call it a crackpot revisionist notion. Source critique must be aimed at the sources the crackpot uses, not merely the revisionistic claim the crackpot is making.

>Since this was brought up in the post, I'll use it as an example. It was said that the story of Finland has been distorted or virtually ignored in the West. Whose fault is that? Is it the Western historians? Is the fault of Finnish historians? These are rhetorical questions that really don't have an answer.

I beg to differ. I think that it is the the western politicians fault (if that can be asserted). They had a guilty conscience and it was cleared when we conveniently gave them an excuse when we, in the absence of an alternative, had to turn to the Germans for help in the prevailing situation. All the good will was nullified when we turned "evil". We were guilty by association. If only things were that simple.

Fri Jun 30 10:44:17 2000


 TIM One true history,one true world (Jun, 28)
 Stephen (AC) Brezinski re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
 Vladimir Starostin re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
Scott Fraser If I Remember Correctly (Jun, 29)
Bob Potter re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 30)
Scott Fraser George and not Carlos? n/t (-) (Jun, 30)
Whitey Bulger It's spelled "SANTAYANA" & you're right, Bob (n/t) (-) (Jul, 4)
Scott Fraser re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
 Arashekino re: Truth is the first casualty of war! (Jun, 29)
 ANZAC Scott ... Brilliant (Jun, 29)
 Jorge Visca re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
 Tero Happy to see it is not only the non-English speaking, ... (Jun, 29)
 Nick re:I AGREE..But ..... (Jun, 29)
Tero Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Men re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Tero Nokia is doing fine, it is the ..... (Jun, 30)
Men re: Nokia is doing fine, it is the ..... (Jun, 30)
 Men re: Nokia is doing fine, it is the ..... (Jun, 30)
 Nick re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
TIM re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Al re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
  • Tero Revisionism is not allways bad (Jun, 30)
  • Scott Fraser re: Facts and opinions (Jun, 29)
    Al re: Facts and opinions (Jun, 30)
    Arashekino re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 30)
    Scott Fraser re: What is to be Done? � 1905 (Jun, 30)
     Nick re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
     Max re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
     Jorge Visca re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
     Men re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
     Jorge Visca re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jul, 1)
    Men re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
     Arashekino re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jul, 1)
    Whitey Bulger re: Gangsters in Siberia!? - I have the answer! (Jul, 2)
     Men re: Gangsters in Siberia!? - I have the answer! (Jul, 2)
     Jorge Visca re: Gangsters in Siberia!? - I have the answer! (Jul, 5)
     ... re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 30)
     Max re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 30)
     Tristan re: Where to begin...... (Jul, 7)
    Scott Fraser Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jun, 30)
     Max Most vital - Oil (Jun, 30)
    Christer Bergstrom Air superiority on the Eastern Front (Jul, 3)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Air superiority on the Eastern Front (Jul, 4)
    Scott Fraser re: Air superiority on the Eastern Front (Jul, 4)
    Tero Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 5)
    Scott Fraser re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 5)
    Tero re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
    Scott Fraser re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
    Tero re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
    Scott Fraser re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
     Jorge Visca re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 7)
    Tero Yak-9 canopy vs Spitfire V canopy (Jul, 7)
    Scott Fraser Spitfire wings (Jul, 7)
    Tero re: Spitfire wings (Jul, 7)
    Tero RAF 155 Sqn with Mk VIII's in Russia in 1943 ???!!!??? (Jul, 7)
    Scott Fraser Hmmmm. (Jul, 7)
    Tero re: Hmmmm. (Jul, 10)
    Scott Fraser re: Hmmmm. (Jul, 11)
    Tero re: Hmmmm. (Jul, 11)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 4)
    Scott Fraser re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 4)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 5)
    Arashekino re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 5)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 6)
    Scott Fraser re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 6)
     clarence morgan samuels (BDA) Bomb Damage Assessment (Jul, 5)
     Jorge Visca What POL stands for? (-) (Jul, 5)
    JWB re: What POL stands for? (Jul, 6)
     Jorge Visca Thanks! (-) (Jul, 7)
     Tero Yes, but..... (Jul, 6)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Yes, but..... (Jul, 7)
    Tero re: Yes, but..... (Jul, 7)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Yes, but..... (Jul, 7)
    Tero Sinister cover ups, distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 10)
    Scott Fraser Coal, steel and synthetic oil production (Jul, 11)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Coal, steel and synthetic oil production (Jul, 11)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Sinister cover ups, distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 11)
    Tero re: Sinister cover ups, distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 11)
     clarence morgan samuels distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 12)
    Tero re: distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 12)
     clarence morgan samuels re: distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 12)
    Tero re: distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 18)
    TIM re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 5)
    Wen Jin Western Propaganda (Jun, 30)
     Men re: Western Propaganda (Jul, 1)
    TIM re: Western Propaganda (Jul, 5)

    Records: 86

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.