Scott Fraser:
re: Facts and opinions
Hi Tim:
Of course we're still arguing! It is the nature of the Beast!
You are wrong, though, to think that history is just opinion. Much popular "history" is just that, but historians trained in a university are instilled with history as a discipline. Scholarly historians still express opinion, but every statement must be supported by reference to source documents which validate the argument. Historians are story-tellers, but academic historians have very strict limits on how much opinion they can inject, and how far they can go without backing up their statements with documentary proof. This is why it is so difficult to write about "modern" history, because so many of these documents are still sealed.
The explosion of publishing since 1945 has made the "history" of the Second World War even more difficult to dissect. If we speak of Napol�on, his Grande Arme� marched into Russia a long time ago. The existing documents have been located and studied a long time ago. The participants have written their memoirs and died, a long time ago, and several generations of ancestors have gone through closets and attics and unearthed any drawings or letters or diaries which might be relevant and they have, for the most part, been placed in the custody of museums and universities. What can be known is known, and for historians, Napol�on is easy to write about. There are a few excellent books written by gifted historians which can be used as a good starting point, and further research might shed a bit of information or a new angle on the story, but it is largely done.
Not so when we move into the Twentieth Century, for the reasons I outlined earlier. It is too soon. The facts are not all in. Instead, we have a sea of books, most written by amateurs, and very many more memoirs and other narratives. In Napol�on's day, the only persons with the time, ability, and inclination to write memoirs were the officers, and they were few in number compared to the other ranks. ...
>>>
Thu Jun 29 22:17:43 2000
TIM
One true history,one true world (Jun, 28)
Stephen (AC) Brezinski
re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
Vladimir Starostin
re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
Scott Fraser
If I Remember Correctly (Jun, 29)
Bob Potter
re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 30)
Scott Fraser
George and not Carlos? n/t (-) (Jun, 30)
Whitey Bulger
It's spelled "SANTAYANA" & you're right, Bob (n/t) (-) (Jul, 4)
Scott Fraser
re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
Arashekino
re: Truth is the first casualty of war! (Jun, 29)
ANZAC
Scott ... Brilliant (Jun, 29)
Jorge Visca
re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
Tero
Happy to see it is not only the non-English speaking, ... (Jun, 29)
Nick
re:I AGREE..But ..... (Jun, 29)
Tero
Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Men
re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Tero
Nokia is doing fine, it is the ..... (Jun, 30)
Men
re: Nokia is doing fine, it is the ..... (Jun, 30)
Men
re: Nokia is doing fine, it is the ..... (Jun, 30)
Nick
re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
TIM
re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Al
re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Tero
Revisionism is not allways bad (Jun, 30)
- Scott Fraser
re: Facts and opinions (Jun, 29)
Al
re: Facts and opinions (Jun, 30)
Arashekino
re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 30)
Scott Fraser
re: What is to be Done? � 1905 (Jun, 30)
Nick
re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
Max
re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
Jorge Visca
re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
Men
re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
Jorge Visca
re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jul, 1)
Men
re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
Arashekino
re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jul, 1)
Whitey Bulger
re: Gangsters in Siberia!? - I have the answer! (Jul, 2)
Men
re: Gangsters in Siberia!? - I have the answer! (Jul, 2)
Jorge Visca
re: Gangsters in Siberia!? - I have the answer! (Jul, 5)
...
re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 30)
Max
re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 30)
Tristan
re: Where to begin...... (Jul, 7)
Scott Fraser
Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jun, 30)
Max
Most vital - Oil (Jun, 30)
Christer Bergstrom
Air superiority on the Eastern Front (Jul, 3)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Air superiority on the Eastern Front (Jul, 4)
Scott Fraser
re: Air superiority on the Eastern Front (Jul, 4)
Tero
Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 5)
Scott Fraser
re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 5)
Tero
re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
Scott Fraser
re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
Tero
re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
Scott Fraser
re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
Jorge Visca
re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 7)
Tero
Yak-9 canopy vs Spitfire V canopy (Jul, 7)
Scott Fraser
Spitfire wings (Jul, 7)
Tero
re: Spitfire wings (Jul, 7)
Tero
RAF 155 Sqn with Mk VIII's in Russia in 1943 ???!!!??? (Jul, 7)
Scott Fraser
Hmmmm. (Jul, 7)
Tero
re: Hmmmm. (Jul, 10)
Scott Fraser
re: Hmmmm. (Jul, 11)
Tero
re: Hmmmm. (Jul, 11)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 4)
Scott Fraser
re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 4)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 5)
Arashekino
re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 5)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 6)
Scott Fraser
re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 6)
clarence morgan samuels
(BDA) Bomb Damage Assessment (Jul, 5)
Jorge Visca
What POL stands for? (-) (Jul, 5)
JWB
re: What POL stands for? (Jul, 6)
Jorge Visca
Thanks! (-) (Jul, 7)
Tero
Yes, but..... (Jul, 6)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Yes, but..... (Jul, 7)
Tero
re: Yes, but..... (Jul, 7)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Yes, but..... (Jul, 7)
Tero
Sinister cover ups, distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 10)
Scott Fraser
Coal, steel and synthetic oil production (Jul, 11)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Coal, steel and synthetic oil production (Jul, 11)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Sinister cover ups, distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 11)
Tero
re: Sinister cover ups, distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 11)
clarence morgan samuels
distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 12)
Tero
re: distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 12)
clarence morgan samuels
re: distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 12)
Tero
re: distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 18)
TIM
re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 5)
Wen Jin
Western Propaganda (Jun, 30)
Men
re: Western Propaganda (Jul, 1)
TIM
re: Western Propaganda (Jul, 5)