Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 James Quinn:
Two theories

Tero, if I understand correctly you contend that France and England never intended to assist Finland, but were using that as a cover story for their real mission, a hostile seizure of the Swedish Iron deposits.

Honestly this sounds like a conspiracy theory to me. I�m far from blind to Allied duplicity during the war, however I am skeptical of the version of events you present. Please, allow me to explain.

There are two competing theories.
First theory - The French and English government form some insane scheme to assist Finland. They bumble and waste time and by the time the necessary military force is getting organized, the struggle is over. An equally insane scheme is cooked up to use the troops to seize the Swedish Iron deposits. Again bumbling and hesitation occurs and the Germans beat the Allies to the punch.

The Evidence to support this version is found in the parliamentary debates, which were occurring over aid to Finland. The public pronouncements of the intention to aid Finland. And the formation of an expeditionary force reportedly for this purpose.

Also supporting this theory is the fact that Finland was in fact supported by some arms sales from France and England during this time.

Finally, politically this makes sense. The French and English governments had locked onto a popular cause that also agreed with their anti-Soviet frame of mind.

History then provides the finally bit of evidence to support this theory. The Norwegian exhibition was in fact carried out. It is well know, and not denied, that the ultimate goal of this mission was to deny the Swedish Iron ore to Germany.

Second Theory - The French and English governments want to seize the Swedish Iron Ore. They decide that intervention in Finland gives them a plausible excuse and so form an army to accomplish this. They are foiled by the sudden Finish collapse. Just the same, they go forward with the expedition, this time with no cover story.

This is plausible, but there are ...

>>> 

Thu Jun 29 06:34:52 2000


 Scott Schaffer Russia as an Axis power (Jun, 27)
 James Quinn The insanity of some Western leaders in 1940/41 (Jun, 27)
 Tero The western historians would like to have you think that is the case (Jun, 27)
 AKV re: Excellent, Tero! (Jun, 27)
 Nick re: Munich;The Czechs were strong enough! (Jun, 27)
 Scott Schaffer I disagree.  (Jun, 28)
 Arashekino re: I disagree.  (Jun, 28)
 HAOster re: I disagree.  (Jul, 5)
 James Quinn A question & my attempt to be more clear (Jun, 28)
 Tero "WWII, as told by W. Churchill, FDR, the war time ... (Jun, 28)
  •  James Quinn Two theories (Jun, 29)
     Tero One more to be added to the pot (Jun, 29)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust Two more books in English (Jun, 29)
     James Quinn Something to think about (Jul, 2)
     Tero OK. We'll me a convert out of you yet. (-) (Jul, 3)
  • Franek Grabowski re: Russia as an Axis power (Jun, 28)
    Jorge Visca re: Russia as an Axis power (Jun, 28)
     Arashekino re: Britain and USA as Axis powers!!! (Jun, 28)
     Arashekino re: I forgot something (Jun, 28)
     Brezinski re: Britain and USA as Axis powers!!! (Jun, 29)
     Arashekino re: My brother in debates (Jun, 29)
    Jorge Visca re: My brother in debates (Jun, 29)
     Amedeo Matteucci re: Russia as an Axis power (Jun, 28)
    Scott Schaffer It's true that the Soviet Union was a de facto ally of Germany.... (Jun, 28)
     Tero the Anglo-French coalition vs the Germanic-Soviet coalition (Jun, 28)
     AKV The Jewish-Bolshevist-Anglo-American-Pluto-Democratic Coalition (Jun, 28)
    Men USSR and axis (Jun, 28)
    TIM re: USSR and axis (Jun, 29)
     James Quinn re: The Jewish-Bolshevist-Anglo-American-Pluto-Democratic Coalition (Jun, 29)
     AKV re: Pluto = Plutocracy (Jun, 29)
     Tero Disney Productions classic "Money talks, Bullshit walks" ? (-) (Jun, 29)
     Amedeo Matteucci Meaning of plutocracy (Jun, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: It's true that the Soviet Union was a de facto ally of Germany.... (Jun, 29)

    Records: 33

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.