Scott Schaffer:
I disagree.
The Czechs had 16 divisions and 600 aircraft, as well as promises of support from the Soviet Union and their own 'little Maginot line'....but if war had come in 1938 they wouldn't have lasted long, I don't think.
Why? Well, for one thing, a healthy chunk (I believe 1/5th or so) of the Czech reservists who made up those 16 divisions were actually Germans....the very Sudentanlanders around whom the crisis revolved. At best, they would be unreliable.
For another, the Soviet Union had no common border with Czechoslovakia, so they would have to cross Polish or Romanian territory to lend support. At this time, it hardly seems likely such permission would be given by either of the powers. Also, the Soviet Union wasn't anywhere near as powerful as it appeared at the time.
And, finally, tying into that was that Czechoslovakia was surrounded by enemies. Germany, Poland, Romania, and Hungary were all eager to claim portions of Czechoslovakia from the Munich summit. At best, these powers would be neutral in a 1938 war, but at worst they might even back the Germans.
The Allies were also even less prepared for war in 1938 then they were in 1939. The Germans were as well, but the Germans still had the edge at that time. My opinion is that a 1938 war would have been by no means an easy one, and might have been even worse for the Allies than the 1939-40 one.
Wed Jun 28 01:33:06 2000
Scott Schaffer
Russia as an Axis power (Jun, 27)
James Quinn
The insanity of some Western leaders in 1940/41 (Jun, 27)
Tero
The western historians would like to have you think that is the case (Jun, 27)
AKV
re: Excellent, Tero! (Jun, 27)
Nick
re: Munich;The Czechs were strong enough! (Jun, 27)
Scott Schaffer
I disagree. (Jun, 28)
Arashekino
re: I disagree. (Jun, 28)
HAOster
re: I disagree. (Jul, 5)
James Quinn
A question & my attempt to be more clear (Jun, 28)
Tero
"WWII, as told by W. Churchill, FDR, the war time ... (Jun, 28)
James Quinn
Two theories (Jun, 29)
Tero
One more to be added to the pot (Jun, 29)
Carl-Fredrik Geust
Two more books in English (Jun, 29)
James Quinn
Something to think about (Jul, 2)
Tero
OK. We'll me a convert out of you yet. (-) (Jul, 3)
Franek Grabowski
re: Russia as an Axis power (Jun, 28)
Jorge Visca
re: Russia as an Axis power (Jun, 28)
Arashekino
re: Britain and USA as Axis powers!!! (Jun, 28)
Arashekino
re: I forgot something (Jun, 28)
Brezinski
re: Britain and USA as Axis powers!!! (Jun, 29)
Arashekino
re: My brother in debates (Jun, 29)
Jorge Visca
re: My brother in debates (Jun, 29)
Amedeo Matteucci
re: Russia as an Axis power (Jun, 28)
Scott Schaffer
It's true that the Soviet Union was a de facto ally of Germany.... (Jun, 28)
Tero
the Anglo-French coalition vs the Germanic-Soviet coalition (Jun, 28)
AKV
The Jewish-Bolshevist-Anglo-American-Pluto-Democratic Coalition (Jun, 28)
Men
USSR and axis (Jun, 28)
TIM
re: USSR and axis (Jun, 29)
James Quinn
re: The Jewish-Bolshevist-Anglo-American-Pluto-Democratic Coalition (Jun, 29)
AKV
re: Pluto = Plutocracy (Jun, 29)
Tero
Disney Productions classic "Money talks, Bullshit walks" ? (-) (Jun, 29)
Amedeo Matteucci
Meaning of plutocracy (Jun, 29)
clarence morgan samuels
re: It's true that the Soviet Union was a de facto ally of Germany.... (Jun, 29)