Max:
re: Again I have to disagree...
I like your analogy with carpenter's tools. We often talk about Western aid that enabled Russians to defeat Germany. But tet's now look at what enabled the German soldier when he invaded Russia in 1941 to achieve all those stunning successes.
It's a long list but let me mention just some of it. Several hundred thousand French trucks (much needed mobility for Blitzkrieg), hundreds of Czech tanks, thousands of MGs and other superb Czech equipment, hundred of thousand of horses stolen from all over Europe (the main driving force of German Blitzkrieg), thousands upon thousands of tons of food, fruit, wine etc. from all corners Europe (Danish meats industries were flourishing on Wehrmacht orders). Well, and not to forget Rumanian oil (without oil the glorious German panzer would've been just a glorious metal box) and Swedish ore, and years of stockpiling Soviet raw materials and wheat before the war. The list may go on and on.
Furthermore, after taking the best part of the soviet union Hitler was able to very effectively pillage clean everything he could lay his hands on - cattle by the million, ore of Nikopol, Ukrainian wheat - you name it. Also Germans "lent" billions in gold from their Jews and then put them in camps. Don't forget millions of slave labor which enabled Germans to free soldiers for eastern front. The whole of Europe with all its industrial might was pitched against Russia in 1941. And at Stalingrad and Moscow, the half-starved but fortified with vodka Russia troops managed to bring about the decision in war against the whole of Europe and long before any western aid arrived in mass.
The question is would the German troops have been able to advance far into Russia in 1941 without Czech, French and other European countries' aid. The answer is no, Russians would've been in Berlin in early 1942. The Blitzkrieg in Russia only materialized because Germany was supported by the whole might of the Western Europe.
Regards
Mon Jun 26 12:19:16 2000
Arashekino
What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 23)
Whitey Bulger
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 23)
Wen Jin
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 24)
Stephen (AC) Brezinski
re: Of course.... (Jun, 24)
Arashekino
re: Of course.... (Jun, 24)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Of course.... (Jun, 24)
Arashekino
re: ? would US do Marshal plan, rebuild Jpn... (Jun, 24)
Stephen (AC) Brezinski
re: If you already knew the outcome.... (Jun, 25)
Heino
Untermenschen????? (Jun, 26)
Henrik Krog
re: Untermenschen????? (Jun, 26)
George W Hogg
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 24)
HAOster
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 24)
TIM
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 24)
Arashekino
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 24)
Stephen (AC) Brezinski
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 25)
Arashekino
re: Respones for the Cutie? (Jun, 25)
Max
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 25)
Stephen (AC) Brezinski
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 25)
Max
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 25)
Stephen (AC) Brezinski
re: Again I have to disagree... (Jun, 26)
Max
re: Again I have to disagree... (Jun, 26)
TIM
re: Again I have to disagree... (Jun, 27)
Arashekino
re: That was a really cool thread! (Jun, 27)
TIM
re: That was a really cool thread! (Jun, 28)
J.W.B.
re: That was a really cool thread! (Jun, 28)
Brezinski
re: Mongolia was a soviet puppet... (Jun, 29)
Arashekino
re: As Latin America was and is an American! (-) (Jun, 29)
TIM
re: Mongolia was a soviet puppet... (Jun, 29)
Jorge Visca
Mongolia. (Jun, 29)
Whitey Bulger
This is a really long thread! (no text) (-) (Jul, 2)
Juris
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 28)
Arashekino
re: You can say whatever you want...... (Jun, 28)
Scott Schaffer
It's been my experience that alternative history.... (Jun, 28)
Arashekino
re: It's been my experience that alternative history.... (Jun, 28)
J.W.B.
re: You can say whatever you want...... (Jun, 28)
Men
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 27)
J.W.B.
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 25)
Arashekino
re: Good reply (Jun, 26)
Henrik Krog
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 26)
Arashekino
re: The best reply to my lame post yet!!! (-) (Jun, 26)
J.W.B.
re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 26)