Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 Max:
re: What if Soviets stopped at border?

"I do not recall seeing anywhere on my messages or anyone elses where the western aid is given full credit for winning the Ost front war."

What is this then?

"I think it is very arrogant to assume that the red army would have defeated the Germans and axis without western help."

You're right about the racer, but the race is not won by the bike but by the man who rides it. Nobody mentions and congratulates the bike after the race is won but the man. It's those who want to belittle the man's victory who point to his bike, saying it's not the man but the bike that won the race.

I don't dislike the fact of the aid, and actually have been always stressing that it greatly, repeat greatly, helped the red army to win the war. I also greatly admire the gallant allied effort. But I'm against such utterances as yours that this aid was decisive.

"Because the western allies had many fewer casualties is as well a tribute to greater western respect for individual life than Stalin, and less a tribute to western allied fear to fight."

You're right that Soviet life was cheap at the time. But more correct answer would be that Soviets had born the brunt of the WW2 fighting, thus giving their Western allies ample time to prepare well and strike with relatively low casualties. According to soviet data, 10,000 Russian soldiers were dying daily in the east throughout the entire war. imagine a Vietnam war in terms of American causalities every five days continuously for four years. This is why I'm saying it's disrespect to say that the price paid in US dollars was just as high.

Regards

Sun Jun 25 23:12:05 2000


 Arashekino What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 23)
Whitey Bulger re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 23)
Wen Jin re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 24)
 Stephen (AC) Brezinski re: Of course.... (Jun, 24)
Arashekino re: Of course.... (Jun, 24)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Of course.... (Jun, 24)
Arashekino re: ? would US do Marshal plan, rebuild Jpn... (Jun, 24)
 Stephen (AC) Brezinski re: If you already knew the outcome.... (Jun, 25)
 Heino Untermenschen????? (Jun, 26)
Henrik Krog re: Untermenschen????? (Jun, 26)
George W Hogg re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 24)
HAOster re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 24)
TIM re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 24)
Arashekino re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 24)
 Stephen (AC) Brezinski re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 25)
 Arashekino re: Respones for the Cutie? (Jun, 25)
 Max re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 25)
 Stephen (AC) Brezinski re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 25)
  •  Max re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 25)
    Stephen (AC) Brezinski re: Again I have to disagree... (Jun, 26)
     Max re: Again I have to disagree... (Jun, 26)
    TIM re: Again I have to disagree... (Jun, 27)
     Arashekino re: That was a really cool thread! (Jun, 27)
    TIM re: That was a really cool thread! (Jun, 28)
    J.W.B. re: That was a really cool thread! (Jun, 28)
    Brezinski re: Mongolia was a soviet puppet... (Jun, 29)
     Arashekino re: As Latin America was and is an American! (-) (Jun, 29)
    TIM re: Mongolia was a soviet puppet... (Jun, 29)
    Jorge Visca Mongolia. (Jun, 29)
    Whitey Bulger This is a really long thread! (no text) (-) (Jul, 2)
  •  Juris re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 28)
     Arashekino re: You can say whatever you want...... (Jun, 28)
     Scott Schaffer It's been my experience that alternative history.... (Jun, 28)
     Arashekino re: It's been my experience that alternative history.... (Jun, 28)
    J.W.B. re: You can say whatever you want...... (Jun, 28)
     Men re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 27)
    J.W.B. re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 25)
     Arashekino re: Good reply (Jun, 26)
     Henrik Krog re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 26)
     Arashekino re: The best reply to my lame post yet!!! (-) (Jun, 26)
    J.W.B. re: What if Soviets stopped at border? (Jun, 26)

    Records: 41

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.