Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 clarence morgan samuels:
re: Could the USSR have won earlier?

"At the time of the German invasion, USSR had in its inventory more than 1000 T-34s and more than 400 KVs. Certainly these vehicles could have been used much more effectively."

Without a doubt. The tactical misuse of AFV was dwarfed by their strategic mis-placement and completely inadequate supply situation(POL&ammunition). I can not begin to numerate the massive losses due to technical failure or lack of fuel/ammunition and horrible placement on the battlefield.

To say that most Soviet tactical commanders lacked situational awareness on or about June 41 is a GROSS understatement.

To some extent I agree with your previous post about the advantage of massive infiltration tactics. The impossibility of coordinating such a maneuver in '41/'42 is evident in the lack of C3I in the Red Army at the time. Such a use of force could have been a disaster for the Heer during the winter '41 counteroffensive. The Wermacht essentialy had a single line of strongpoints that could have been bypassed and swarped by just such tactics. Unfortunatly most of the points were struck head on and massive casualties ensued. I chalk this one up to zero situational awareness. It took lots of precious time for the tactical commanders to get a clue as to how to fight a modern war, and time for industry/lend-lease to provide the C3I equipment necessry to spread battlfield intelligence up and down their chain of command.

"The SA had only 1.5-1 advantage because Soviet officers would spend men by the thousands in wastefull attacks and shrug their shoulders and walk away."

Again I say bad situational awareness. Zhukov forbade head on assaults very early on. The problem is that many commanders had almost no knowledge of where the enemy actualy was. How can you bypass a foe when his location is a mystery and you have to be on your objective in a short period of time? Often there was nothing for it but a direct advance into the "fog of war."

"Regiments would be used to clear minefields by ...

>>> 

Sat Jun 24 11:48:58 2000


 Arashekino Could the USSR have won earlier? (-) (Jun, 18)
Stephen (AC) B re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 18)
Arashekino re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 19)
Wen Jin re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 19)
Henry Oster re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 20)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 19)
Mike Jasinski re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 19)
Alex Hellmund Some suggestions (Jun, 20)
Alex Hellmund General Observation (Jun, 20)
 Wen Jin re: General Observation (Jun, 20)
Stephen (AC) B re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 20)
J.W.B. re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 23)
Mikhail re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 23)
 Wen Jin re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 24)
J.W.B. re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 24)
  •  clarence morgan samuels re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 24)
    J.W.B. re: Could the USSR have won earlier? (Jun, 25)
  • HAOster re: Infiltration (Jun, 24)

    Records: 18

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.