Wen Jin:
re: FIGURES A Fairer Ratio
Actually, at Berlin (including garrisons around the city), the Germans had 300,000 dead and 500,000 prisoners (out of an original force of about 1,000,000. The Red Army didn't fare badly there, as they stayed away from the streets, avoiding the killing zones and advanced through basements and buildings. Seelow Heights was just a disaster, plain and simple.
Most of the time, though, the Germans were not as skilled in barricade warfare as the Russians (General D�rr admitted this at Stalingrad). Often, their city defenses were disasterous, as shown in the defense of Kharkov in Aug '44. The Germans had fortified the city, mining and barricading all approaches, but the Soviets attacked on the night of Aug. 22/23, filtering past their defenses and surprising them from behind. Kharkov was cleared by midday on the 23rd.
Ideally, the defender can inflict more casualties, but that does not always happen. The crossing of the Dniepr was envisoned by the Nazis to be a meatgrinder. As Hitler said, "The Dniepr will flow backwards before the Russians overcome this powerful 800-yard-wide river line." However, the Germans were the ones who found themselves desperately throwing themselves at the Russians with everything they had. They launched counterattacks at the beachheads 10-12 times a day and suffered very heavy losses in the process.
Sat Jun 24 05:52:16 2000
Arashekino
Comparative values for western allies (Jun, 18)
Wen Jin
re: Comparative values for western allies (Jun, 18)
Max
FIGURES (Jun, 18)
Samuel
re: FIGURES (Jun, 19)
clarence morgan samuels
re: FIGURES (Jun, 19)
Arashekino
re: FIGURES (Jun, 19)
Max
re: FIGURES (Jun, 19)
Steve Cormier
re: FIGURES (Jun, 19)
Wen Jin
re: FIGURES (Jun, 20)
George W Hogg
re: FIGURES A Fairer Ratio (Jun, 22)
Wen Jin
re: FIGURES A Fairer Ratio (Jun, 23)
George W Hogg
re: FIGURES A Fairer Ratio (Jun, 24)
- Wen Jin
re: FIGURES A Fairer Ratio (Jun, 24)
Arashekino
Interesting what are your sources? (Jun, 24)
Wen Jin
re: Interesting what are your sources? (Jun, 24)
TIM
re: Interesting what are your sources? (Jun, 24)
Wen Jin
oops, typo (Jun, 24)