Wen Jin:
re: FIGURES A Fairer Ratio
Do you mean 3:1 in favor of the attacker or defender? In 1944, the Red Army never had more than a 1.5:1 numerical superiority. I believe that the Soviet tactic of bypassing strongpoints, coupled with the German "no retreat" directive, shifted the balance decisively to the Red Army, as pockets of resistance could be isolated and contained. Casualty rates were about the same or even in favor of the Red Army because the Germans were often rushed in desperately to fill gaps, without time to dig in, as in the battles in the Ukraine. The Soviet Union had only a modest superiority in men, but a massive mechanical advantage, especially in artillery and aircraft. For the Baltic offensive, the Red Army had a 1.3:1 superiority in manpower, a 2.5:1 superiority in armor, a 2.5:1 superiority in artillery, and an 8:1 superiority in aircraft. To say that the Germans had a 3:1 kill ratio is ridiculous; the Red Army would have been bled dry within a month and would not have been able to advance 300 miles.
Fri Jun 23 05:48:33 2000
Arashekino
Comparative values for western allies (Jun, 18)
Wen Jin
re: Comparative values for western allies (Jun, 18)
Max
FIGURES (Jun, 18)
Samuel
re: FIGURES (Jun, 19)
clarence morgan samuels
re: FIGURES (Jun, 19)
Arashekino
re: FIGURES (Jun, 19)
Max
re: FIGURES (Jun, 19)
Steve Cormier
re: FIGURES (Jun, 19)
Wen Jin
re: FIGURES (Jun, 20)
George W Hogg
re: FIGURES A Fairer Ratio (Jun, 22)
- Wen Jin
re: FIGURES A Fairer Ratio (Jun, 23)
George W Hogg
re: FIGURES A Fairer Ratio (Jun, 24)
Wen Jin
re: FIGURES A Fairer Ratio (Jun, 24)
Arashekino
Interesting what are your sources? (Jun, 24)
Wen Jin
re: Interesting what are your sources? (Jun, 24)
TIM
re: Interesting what are your sources? (Jun, 24)
Wen Jin
oops, typo (Jun, 24)