Alex Wood:
re: IS-II Combat Performance
I don't know where you read the that A19 was inferior to all those other weapons.
The following is taken from Soviet Heavy Tanks by S J Zaloga & J Grandsen - Osprey Vanguard no.24.
"In November 1943 the IS-122 was demonstrated at the Kubinka Proving Grounds...first round at 1,500m ripped through the thick frontal armour of a captured Panther, and blasted out through the rear hull armour"
"The 122mm gun offered 2.7 times more kinetic energy on impact than the 85mm gun, and 3.5 times more than the old 76.2mm weapon. Firing the BR-471 APHE round it could penetrate 160mm of armour at 1,000m"
"The IS-2 was invulnerable to the standard 88mm AP round at ranges over 1,000m when fired against the frontal quadrant"
"The only shortcoming was the rate of fire, slowed to about two or three rounds a minute by the use of a two-piece round...A partial remedy adopted on 1944 production models was the improved D-25T gun, which had a handier drop breech instead of the conventional artillery screw-breech."
This from Hasso von Manteuffel;
"Our Tigers met the Stalins for the first time...in May 1944 in Romania during the battle for Targal Frumos...Not having seen this type before, our Tigers opened fire from 3,000m, and noted that the 88mm rounds ricocheted off the armour!...This encounter was shocking, as previously our 88mm gun had destroyed Russian tanks with direct hits at maximum range without difficulty. Now the Tiger crews could destroy the enemy tanks only with the greatest difficulty and suffering heavy losses."
Things to remember about the IS-2 it is in the same weight and size class as the Panther, a medium tank (!?), and much lighter than a Tiger - the Russians called the IS-2 a heavy tank and used it as such.
Sun Jun 18 15:11:39 2000
Steve Cormier
IS-II Combat Performance (Jun, 14)
Alex Wood
re: IS-II Combat Performance (Jun, 18)
Dave
re: IS-II Combat Performance (Jul, 23)
Dave
re: IS-II Combat Performance...here is the site (Jul, 23)