Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Scott Fraser:
re: Stuka vs. Sturmovik

The Ju-87 was not a ground-attack aircraft, any more than the He-111 was. Both aircraft dropped bombs, which happened to hit the ground, and that's as far as it went.

The Ju-87 was designed from the outset as a dive-bomber, pure and simple. The name "Stuka" is an abbreviation of the German term Sturzkampfflugzeug, literally dive-(bombing)-aircraft. The only true ground-attack in the Luftwaffe inventory were the Henschel Hs-123 and the Hs-129. Later in the war, the Fw-190 was adapted for this purpose, but it was designed as a fighter. The German word Schlachtflugzeug (battle aircraft) was used to describe ground-attack aircraft, quite separately from dive bombers.

The difference is in tactics and deployment. Stukas delivered a large bomb from altitude in a steep dive, followed by climb and escape. They did not loiter to strafe, as their armament was quite inadequate to that task. Ground attack aircraft operated at a lower altitude, delivered smaller bombs in greater number, and had much heavier automatic weapons (cannon) and generally better armour than the Ju-87. They hung around the battlefield, seeking targets of opportunity, whereas the Stuka were generally dispatched to specific targets.

Rudel's experiments with 37mm cannon mounted under the wing of the Ju-87 were an anomaly, and there were never very many of these aircraft. They were not automatic weapons, but semi-automatic, with very limited ammunition. They cannot be compared with the fully automatic 20/30mm cannon of the Hs-129 or the 23mm cannon of the Il-2.

The lack of an effective ground-attack aircraft = close-support aircraft was a handicap to German ground troops. The lack of this capability was not anticipated when the Ju-87 entered service. The Hs-123 was taken out of production, despite the excellent record the type had in Spain, and the Henschels were sent to flying schools. Wolfram Von Richtofen, commander of the Legion Condor at the end of the Spanish ...

>>> 

Fri Jun 16 08:55:30 2000


 Nick Stuka vs. Sturmovik (Jun, 14)
Men re: Stuka vs. Sturmovik (Jun, 14)
 Nick re: Stuka vs. Sturmovik (Jun, 14)
Max re: Stuka vs. Sturmovik (Jun, 14)
George Hogg re: Stuka vs. Sturmovik (Jun, 15)
 D�nes Bernad re: Stuka vs. Shturmovik (Jun, 16)
  • Scott Fraser re: Stuka vs. Sturmovik (Jun, 16)
    John Kahl re: Stuka vs. Sturmovik (Jun, 20)
  • radik re: Stuka vs. Sturmovik (Jun, 15)
    Shveik re: Stuka vs. Sturmovik (Jun, 15)
    Scott Fraser re: Stuka in the Mediterranean (Jun, 16)

    Records: 11

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.