Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 clarence morgan samuels:
re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR

"The average number of German casualties in the East derived from various sources (OKW, OKH, Seaton) is 1,500,000 dead and around 1,300,000 missing. How many of these missing do you think were actually POW?"

I am quite willing to stipulate that many of the MIA were in actuality POW and so should not be counted twice. 70% sounds fair.

"So now we have 1,500,000 mn KIA"

That is less by 25% of the source I have been quoting. But for the sake of clearing the arguments I am willing to go with this figure if it makes you happy. Personally it think it was closer to 2 million but that's just me. When you add in your speculation that of the MIA 300k were KIAs then your figure approaches mine.

"1,000,000 POW and 300,000 MIA (dead). Let's add the German troops that surrendered to Russians in 1945. According to Soviet sources they numbered about 1.5 mn."

Your POW figure is 1 million less than the numbers I have been using even if you add the 1.5 million captured at the end of the war.

I think your POW figure for the Wermacht is way too low.

"4,000,000 WIA
Total: 8,300,000."

I thought we were only going to count those who were total losses? Those who were wounded but returned to duty should not count IMO.

"I think it would be only fair to exclude allies of both sides (Polish, Czech, Rumanian troops fighting for Russians and axis troops fighting for Germans."

I do not think that is a good idea. Many of the divisions levied in Poland and other states fought under the banner of the Red Army and their losses would be included in the Soviet figures.

"Now let's see Soviet figures.I insist on using TOTAL losses.
According to Krivosheev the total Soviet losses were 29,000,000"

That is completely unfair. COMPLETELY. Wounded and returned to duty don't cound. Sick don't count. Frostbitten don't count.

"So the ratio is still 3.4 to 1. Even if we add axis states casualties the ratio is still 3 to 1."

I could not dissagree more.

I will be looking further into the Axis losses. I realy think you are stretching things here.

Fri Jun 16 02:47:44 2000


 Arashekino Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 14)
 George Hogg re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 14)
 Max re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 14)
Henrik Krog re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 14)
 Max re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 14)
Arashekino re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 14)
Igor Galperin re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 16)
Igor Galperin re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 16)
 Arashekino re: Why these #s are rediculous (Jun, 16)
Igor Galperin re: Why these #s are rediculous (Jun, 19)
 Arashekino re: Igor, thanx for the response pls E-mail article (-) (Jun, 20)
 Max re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 16)
 Arashekino re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 14)
 Max re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 14)
 George Hogg re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 15)
Henry Oster re: "Supermen" (Jun, 22)
 Wen Jin Re: Supermen (Jun, 23)
HAOster re: Re: Supermen (Jun, 24)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 15)
 Max re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 15)
George Hogg re: Make your mind up Max (Jun, 15)
  •  clarence morgan samuels re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 16)
  •  Max To morgan Samuels (Jun, 16)
     Mitch Williamson re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 15)
    Arashekino re: Comparative Casualties Axis to USSR (Jun, 16)
    Jari Lievonen Austrians are most likely included in German losses (Jun, 16)
     Mitch Williamson re:Now I understand-read it incorrectly. Thanks (N/T) (Jun, 16)
     Arashekino Conclusions and new questions (Jun, 17)
    Wen Jin re: Conclusions and new questions (Jun, 18)

    Records: 29

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.