Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Carl-Fredrik Geust:
Answer to Henrik Krog

Henrik,

I apologize for expressing myself too categorically - you are correct that parts of the Soviet 289 and 176 divisions were able to break out of the Finnish encirclement at Ilomantsi 6...9.8.44, however with big losses (over 1200 killed left behind, estimated 2000 wounded) and also leaving most of the heavy equipment and division archives behind (the Finns captured eg. 94 artillery guns, 6 rocket launchers, 82 mortars, 7 tanks, 66 trucks, over 200 horses etc; there was no time to perform full analysis of the division archives before the cease fire. The entire Finnish intelligence archives were subsequently sent to Sweden 19-20 Sept 1944, and have never turned up; some fragments can be located in the War archive).

None of the two Soviet divisions concerned was judged to be capable of fighting by the Finnish army before practically complete replenishment of men and equipment.

I have not the book by Kuussari-Niitemaa at this moment, but know it to some extent. The first edition was published in 1948 (when the Finnish War archive was almost totally inaccessible, execpt with special, limited permission). Thus this book is no longer considered to be a reliable source.

A peculiar point is that for political reasons the Finnish army and in particular the officers and units resonsible for the successful attacks against these Soviet divisions were never given full acknowledgement and honors not at the time nor later - naturally leading to certain bitterness and bad feelings. Only a few years ago the first detailled study of this battle was published, named "At last victory" (in Finnish only - the title naturally referring to the retreat of Finnish army in June-July 1944) - this book clearly indicates the political pressure in Finland to play down the significance of this battle in order not to irritate the victors.
regards
Carl

Sat Jun 3 20:50:21 2000


Scott Schaffer Finland (Jun, 2)
 Juha re: Finland (Jun, 2)
 Mikhail re: Finland (Jun, 2)
 Stephen B. re: How much do you ... (Jun, 2)
Henrik Krog Probably..... (Jun, 2)
Juha re: How much do you ... (Jun, 2)
Scott Fraser re: Finland postwar (Jun, 2)
Robert A. Mosher re: Finland (and Bulgaria) (Jun, 2)
Scott Fraser In the beginning . . . (Jun, 4)
Carl-Fredrik Geust re: In the beginning . . . (Jun, 4)
Tero The role of the British delegates and Marshall aid (Jun, 4)
Jari Lievonen re: The role of the British delegates and Marshall aid (Jun, 5)
Tero re: In the beginning . . . (Jun, 4)
 Ilkka Mutanen Some thoughts (Jun, 3)
 Tero My top 4 list of reasons (Jun, 3)
Carl-Fredrik Geust Some additional comments (Jun, 3)
Henrik Krog As to your point 1  (Jun, 3)
 Max re: As to your point 1  (Jun, 3)
 Arashekino re: As to your point 1  (Jun, 3)
Arashekino re: Another thought (Jun, 3)
 Tero An MO forming already then ? (Jun, 4)
 Mikhail Bulgaria (Jun, 5)
Tero re: As to your point 1  (Jun, 4)
 Ilkka Mutanen Stalin was serious  (Jun, 3)
 Max re: Stalin was serious  (Jun, 4)
Carl-Fredrik Geust re: Stalin was serious  (Jun, 4)
Tero "Clear exaggeration" ? (Jun, 4)
Jari Lievonen Russian losses summer 1944 (Jun, 5)
 Ilkka Mutanen Sorry, I was unclear (Jun, 9)
Tero Both the 1939 and the 1944 go's were serious (Jun, 4)
  • Carl-Fredrik Geust Answer to Henrik Krog  (Jun, 3)
    Mathias Forsberg Finnish documents (Jun, 4)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: "Stella Polaris" and Finnish documents (Jun, 4)
  • Records: 33

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.