Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 Tero:
My top 4 list of reasons

1. First and foremost: Finnish territory was not strategically important enough to warrant large scale occupation forces and guerrilla war that would have followed the occupation. The geo-political realities outweighed the lust to regain pre-1917 borders. The Red Army was engaged in a guerilla war in the Ukraine for years after the war and that was bad enough without having to wage war on foreign soil without good cause. Soviet leaders forgot that in Afganistan and now later in Chechenia.

2. Respect: Yes, Stalin toasted the Finnish army for its valour after the war. It had inflicted serious enough casualties to command Stalins respect. I think that is one of the reasons why he "ordered" its emasculation by denying certain types of weapon systems and other restrictions. We got to keep the largest reservist army of the west but were not allowed for example missiles for decades. He cut the nails and teeth of the lion but he dared not try to kill it. It may just be that he needed Finland as a showpiece in case he forgot what it meant to go to war againts a motivated enemy, even if it was poorly equipped.

3. The USA and the UK leaders felt they should do at least something so that not ALL the countries east of Oder fell under communist rule. Their wishes may or may not have had an effect on Stalin though. I think Finland was the only player he could be generous with if he so wished without endangering his strategical position. He had no such choices in central Europe.

Some considerations: FDR had played both ends of the table during Winter War, trying to manouvre USA from entering war prematurely. He gave us PR peanuts while he supplied and supported the USSR. Perhaps FDR felt a sting for acting "immorally" towards a democratic state fighting for its life. Churchill on the other had utilized the debacle of the "military aid to Finland" force in Norway, which was the demise of Chamberlines political career. The conduct of the Brits is a puzzle. They voiced strong support during Winter War but did nothing concrete. They deglared war on us in 1941 in support of Stalin. They made only one token raid on the harbour of Turku but the crews jetisoned the bombs well before the target (again nothing concrete except huff and puff). After the war their delagates in the oversight commitee were even more hawkish that their Soviet counterparts.

4. Stalin expected the Finnish communists to take over and did not want to waste any resources. The communists failed and by then Stalin was preoccupied with the arms race with the USA to be bothered by a situation that was already taken care of by other arrangements.

Sat Jun 3 01:59:00 2000


Scott Schaffer Finland (Jun, 2)
 Juha re: Finland (Jun, 2)
 Mikhail re: Finland (Jun, 2)
 Stephen B. re: How much do you ... (Jun, 2)
Henrik Krog Probably..... (Jun, 2)
Juha re: How much do you ... (Jun, 2)
Scott Fraser re: Finland postwar (Jun, 2)
Robert A. Mosher re: Finland (and Bulgaria) (Jun, 2)
Scott Fraser In the beginning . . . (Jun, 4)
Carl-Fredrik Geust re: In the beginning . . . (Jun, 4)
Tero The role of the British delegates and Marshall aid (Jun, 4)
Jari Lievonen re: The role of the British delegates and Marshall aid (Jun, 5)
Tero re: In the beginning . . . (Jun, 4)
 Ilkka Mutanen Some thoughts (Jun, 3)
  •  Tero My top 4 list of reasons (Jun, 3)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust Some additional comments (Jun, 3)
    Henrik Krog As to your point 1  (Jun, 3)
     Max re: As to your point 1  (Jun, 3)
     Arashekino re: As to your point 1  (Jun, 3)
    Arashekino re: Another thought (Jun, 3)
     Tero An MO forming already then ? (Jun, 4)
     Mikhail Bulgaria (Jun, 5)
    Tero re: As to your point 1  (Jun, 4)
     Ilkka Mutanen Stalin was serious  (Jun, 3)
     Max re: Stalin was serious  (Jun, 4)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: Stalin was serious  (Jun, 4)
    Tero "Clear exaggeration" ? (Jun, 4)
    Jari Lievonen Russian losses summer 1944 (Jun, 5)
     Ilkka Mutanen Sorry, I was unclear (Jun, 9)
    Tero Both the 1939 and the 1944 go's were serious (Jun, 4)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust Answer to Henrik Krog  (Jun, 3)
    Mathias Forsberg Finnish documents (Jun, 4)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: "Stella Polaris" and Finnish documents (Jun, 4)
  • Records: 33

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.