Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 Ilkka Mutanen:
Some thoughts

Scott and others,

I agree that politics had much to do with the case Finland in 1944 and forward, but I must remind you all that the political solution was possible only after Soviets were stopped in terms of military.

Indeed the Red army was different than it was in 1939, but...

1. As been said, the Red army had a shortage of manpower in summer 1944.

2. It was still operationally inflexible if compared to German or Finnish army. Please not forget those two Soviet rifle divisions, that were surrounded in forests of Ilomantsi. Also, pay attention that despite of huge material superiority the Soviet advance in Karelian Isthmus were not as fast as Finnish advance had been in 1941, that tells us it was not too easy for the Red army. Major Soviet thrusts to get forward were contained at Vuosalmi and Tali-Ihantala. Soviet failure to take full advantage of their airpower was also an important factor when considering the final result of the battle, which in fact very much reminds of the 1939-40 battle, although in 1944 the Finnish army was not as exhausted than in 1940. During the latter phases of the winter war I think the situation was much more critical than during autumn 1944.

Regards,

Ilkka



Sat Jun 3 00:15:32 2000


Scott Schaffer Finland (Jun, 2)
 Juha re: Finland (Jun, 2)
 Mikhail re: Finland (Jun, 2)
 Stephen B. re: How much do you ... (Jun, 2)
Henrik Krog Probably..... (Jun, 2)
Juha re: How much do you ... (Jun, 2)
Scott Fraser re: Finland postwar (Jun, 2)
Robert A. Mosher re: Finland (and Bulgaria) (Jun, 2)
Scott Fraser In the beginning . . . (Jun, 4)
Carl-Fredrik Geust re: In the beginning . . . (Jun, 4)
Tero The role of the British delegates and Marshall aid (Jun, 4)
Jari Lievonen re: The role of the British delegates and Marshall aid (Jun, 5)
Tero re: In the beginning . . . (Jun, 4)
  •  Ilkka Mutanen Some thoughts (Jun, 3)
     Tero My top 4 list of reasons (Jun, 3)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust Some additional comments (Jun, 3)
    Henrik Krog As to your point 1  (Jun, 3)
     Max re: As to your point 1  (Jun, 3)
     Arashekino re: As to your point 1  (Jun, 3)
    Arashekino re: Another thought (Jun, 3)
     Tero An MO forming already then ? (Jun, 4)
     Mikhail Bulgaria (Jun, 5)
    Tero re: As to your point 1  (Jun, 4)
     Ilkka Mutanen Stalin was serious  (Jun, 3)
     Max re: Stalin was serious  (Jun, 4)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: Stalin was serious  (Jun, 4)
    Tero "Clear exaggeration" ? (Jun, 4)
    Jari Lievonen Russian losses summer 1944 (Jun, 5)
     Ilkka Mutanen Sorry, I was unclear (Jun, 9)
    Tero Both the 1939 and the 1944 go's were serious (Jun, 4)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust Answer to Henrik Krog  (Jun, 3)
    Mathias Forsberg Finnish documents (Jun, 4)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: "Stella Polaris" and Finnish documents (Jun, 4)
  • Records: 33

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.