Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 Scott Schaffer:
Not entirely true.

Losses aren't by any means the only way to change doctrine. The ideas of Americans in 1945 were nowhere close to the ideas of Americans in the late 19th century, or even the beginning of the 20th, when the aforementioned Filipino insurrection occured, I'm sure you would agree. Yet, there was no war lost in the interim.

You're right that losses can be a sort of 'rude awakening' and change policy, but I hardly think the United States army of 1945 can be fairly compared to the one that conquered the West. Its like trying to compare the Red Army to the army of Catherine the Great; same country, wildly different times.

As for No Gun Ri, thats hardly what I would call 'policy'. Atrocities happen in all armies, but incidents do not a policy make.

Thu Jun 1 07:08:11 2000


 George Hogg USA/USSR continuation War ( what if) (May, 30)
 Arashekino re: USA/USSR continuation War ( what if) (May, 30)
 Nick re: Massacred Partisans? (May, 30)
 Max you need evidence!!! (May, 30)
 Nick re: Differant War (May, 30)
 Mikhail re: Differant War (May, 30)
 Nick re: Differant War (May, 30)
 Mikhail re: Differant War (May, 30)
 George W Hogg re: Differant War (May, 30)
Lee Dowd re: Differant War (May, 30)
 Mikhail re: Differant War (May, 30)
Lee Dowd re: Differant War (May, 30)
 Mikhail re: Differant War (May, 30)
Lee Dowd re: Differant War (May, 31)
 Arashekino America lost because we believed propaganda! (May, 31)
Samuel Suchet (May, 31)
George W Hogg re: Massacred Partisans? (May, 30)
Arashekino re: Massacred Partisans? (May, 31)
Scott Schaffer I think you're looking too far back (May, 31)
 Arashekino re: I don't think so (May, 31)
 Arashekino re: We beat the horse, what about Military aspects? (-) (May, 31)
Lee Dowd re: We beat the horse, what about Military aspects? (May, 31)
Lee Dowd re: I don't think so (May, 31)
  •  Scott Schaffer Not entirely true.  (Jun, 1)
  • Lee Dowd Biological warfare who was first? was re: Massacred Partisans? (May, 31)
     Nick re: First Bio-Warfare,1346AD!!! (May, 31)
    Stephen Brezinski re: Difference between policy and impulse... (May, 31)
     Max re: Difference between policy and impulse... (May, 31)
    Stephen B re: Difference between policy and impulse... (Jun, 1)
     Arashekino Sorry, Americans are cuties!!! (Jun, 1)
     Arashekino How about continuation at time of Korea??? (Jun, 1)
     Arashekino For responses to your comments see Politics (-) (Jun, 1)

    Records: 32

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.