Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Steve Cormier:
re: Still Puzzled By FDR

George Hogg,

I've read in more than one place that a dictator is really the "best" leader to fight a war. Stalin, who's direction and tactics may have killed as many of his troops as the Germans did, was probably the best leader to lead Russia to defeat the Germans on the eastern front. That is, another Russian leader may have saved more lives, but at the expense of a military victory. However, the Russians weren't willing to settle for anything less than a military victory. Stalin needed it to galvanize a nation under his banner and vision, and the Russian people demanded it - practically regardless of the cost.

That said, FDR shouldn't be too much of a mystery once you understand the American mentality towards war. The average American was far removed from the war in Europe up to 1941, relatively speaking, and, seeing how they often think of themselves as the center of the universe (yes, I'm an American going back at least nine generations), they couldn't see what they could get out of an entanglement in Europe. WWI was still a sore point with most and little had come out of it for the average America outside of a sense of pride (most which believe was misplaced) that couldn't compensate for the loss of loved ones. America, priding itself on "we the people" and the democratic way, view things like war in term of popular opinion. That is, the people have to be behind it. Although this usually takes a significant event - at least in our minds - to trigger a response (the sinking of the USS Maine, the sinking of the Lusitannia, Pearl Harbor), we go kicking and screaming into war and, then once committed, it's victory or nothing. The kicking and screaming comes from self-centeredness. The commitment comes from being prideful and arrogant.

FDR convinced Americans on their involvement, and commitment, to the war. I recognize that I will get arguments all day long that it was the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor triggered this commitment. Granted. However, the Japanese attack was a much provoked - which they've professed all along - by the intentional or unintentional policies of FDR. FDR saw the war as a matter of mission, the legacy of America to defend the oppressed and fight for freedom over tyranny. That it would helped pulled his nation out of the depression probably wasn't lost on him either.

I don't know of any particular book offhand that focuses on his wartime leadership, though I'm sure there are plenty. Most of what I've read about FDR has been gleaned from several sources about the war. All of the above is my opinion based on the summations of what I've read and how Americans have traditionally faced the prospect of war.

Thu Jun 1 04:31:29 2000


 George Hogg Who was the most effective war leader ? (May, 23)
 Max re: Who was the most effective war leader ? (May, 23)
 Amedeo Matteucci re: Who was the most effective war leader ? (May, 23)
Robert A. Mosher re: Who was the most effective war leader ? (May, 23)
 Anatoly re: Who was the most effective war leader ? (May, 24)
Lee Dowd re: Who was the most effective war leader ? (May, 24)
 Max Efficiency means little blood!!!! (May, 24)
Ales Gelogaev re: Who was the most effective war leader ? (May, 24)
 Nick re: WHEN BRITAIN STOOD ALONE!! (May, 24)
 Arashekino re: Tito and Mao (May, 24)
 Nick re: Periphery? (May, 24)
 Al re: Periphery? (May, 24)
 Mikhail Leaders and Generals and Such (May, 24)
Steve Cormier re: Leaders and Generals and Such (Jun, 1)
 Arashekino re: Periphery? (May, 25)
Lee Dowd re: Periphery? (May, 25)
George Hogg re: Still Puzzled By FDR (May, 26)
  • Steve Cormier re: Still Puzzled By FDR (Jun, 1)
    George W Hogg re: Still Puzzled By FDR (Jun, 2)
    Steve Cormier re: Still Puzzled By FDR (Jun, 8)
     Nick re: Still Puzzled By FDR (Jun, 7)
    Henry Oster re: Still Puzzled By FDR (Jun, 20)
  • Records: 22

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.