Stephen Brezinski:
re: Difference between policy and impulse...
In every war in the heat of killing and seeing your friends being killed atrocities are commited by average men. This happened in Normandy, Afganistan, Vietnam, Chechnia, Lebanon, the Great Patriotic War. This happens in all wars and is to be expected knowing humans, though I condem it and those responsibe should be condemed for it.
What is different and we need to seperate is when it is government policy and not impulse of men in the field. Extermination by policy (ethnic cleansing) examples are the Turkish extermination of many of its Armenian population in 1917, the USA's exterminnation of many Native Americans in the 1870's, The USSR's starving of many Ukrainians in the 1930's, Nazi concentration camps and starving of many Soviet citizens in 1941-44, the Katyn massacre of Polish officers by the NKVD in 1940, Serbian concentration camps in the 1990's, the extermination of so many Africans in their latest civil wars, and the ethnic cleansing of Eastern Poland and Eastern Germany by the Soviets in 1939 and in 1945 (recall that, to put it simply, the USSR took half of Poland in 1939 when it invaded with Germany and then compensated in 1945 by giving several provinces of Germany to Poland and forcebly expelling its German population).
I do not, and cannot, believe that the US had a policy of exterminating captured partisans and civilians in SE Asia in the 1960-70's or Europe in the 1940's. I beleive it did happen, but on local impulse and fear. The US press is too open and would love to expose something like this such as it did with Mie Lay and Watergate, and the trajic killing of Korean civilians in 1950. (please excuse my misspellings :-} )
Wed May 31 19:03:50 2000
George Hogg
USA/USSR continuation War ( what if) (May, 30)
Arashekino
re: USA/USSR continuation War ( what if) (May, 30)
Nick
re: Massacred Partisans? (May, 30)
Max
you need evidence!!! (May, 30)
Nick
re: Differant War (May, 30)
Mikhail
re: Differant War (May, 30)
Nick
re: Differant War (May, 30)
Mikhail
re: Differant War (May, 30)
George W Hogg
re: Differant War (May, 30)
Lee Dowd
re: Differant War (May, 30)
Mikhail
re: Differant War (May, 30)
Lee Dowd
re: Differant War (May, 30)
Mikhail
re: Differant War (May, 30)
Lee Dowd
re: Differant War (May, 31)
Arashekino
America lost because we believed propaganda! (May, 31)
Samuel
Suchet (May, 31)
George W Hogg
re: Massacred Partisans? (May, 30)
Arashekino
re: Massacred Partisans? (May, 31)
Scott Schaffer
I think you're looking too far back (May, 31)
Arashekino
re: I don't think so (May, 31)
Arashekino
re: We beat the horse, what about Military aspects? (-) (May, 31)
Lee Dowd
re: We beat the horse, what about Military aspects? (May, 31)
Lee Dowd
re: I don't think so (May, 31)
Scott Schaffer
Not entirely true. (Jun, 1)
Lee Dowd
Biological warfare who was first? was re: Massacred Partisans? (May, 31)
Nick
re: First Bio-Warfare,1346AD!!! (May, 31)
- Stephen Brezinski
re: Difference between policy and impulse... (May, 31)
Max
re: Difference between policy and impulse... (May, 31)
Stephen B
re: Difference between policy and impulse... (Jun, 1)
Arashekino
Sorry, Americans are cuties!!! (Jun, 1)
Arashekino
How about continuation at time of Korea??? (Jun, 1)
Arashekino
For responses to your comments see Politics (-) (Jun, 1)