Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 James Quinn:
re: Czechoslovakia was no pushover

Mr. Fraser, Thank you for your response.

I do have a few follow-up comments.

>�Hitler would not have been able to concentrate his forces against Czechoslovakia, either, lest the French decide to retake the Rhineland in retaliation. It was only after Chamberlain and Daladier had given their assurances that they would not attack Germany that he felt free to pursue his aggression in the East.�

I do not believe that Chamberlain and Daladier ever gave the Nazi�s written assurances that they would not attack in response to Eastern Aggression. Perhaps the Nazi�s were lead to understand that they would not be attacked, but no formal assurance was ever given. England and France�s abandonment of the Czechoslovakians was shameful, but not this shameful.

I must disagree with you another aspect of the above quote. While they would not tell Germany this, I do not believe that the French were going to invade Germany in 1938 no matter what happened in the East. I have written a somewhat lengthy post about this for a different forum that I could copy to this forum if you were interested in my reasoning.

>�The Czech armed forces, had they resisted, could have given the Germans a great deal of trouble. There can be no Blitzkrieg without tanks, and in 1938 the best the Germans could field were the PzKpfw I and a few PzKpfw IIs. In contrast, the Czechs hads the excellent �koda LT Vz.35 and the TNH LT Vz.38, better known as the PzKpfw 35(t) and PzKpfw 38(t). The Germans had nothing comparable.�

A small thing here. The Czechoslovakian military did not yet posses many TNH LT Vz.38�s. This vehicle was only starting to be delivered and it was available in very small numbers at the time of the Munich Crisis. No big matter however as the Vz.35 would have still been a match for anything the Germans would have had available.

The biggest shortcoming of the Czechoslovakian military was not their equipment, which was on the whole very good; it was their military doctrine. The Czechoslovakian military had chosen to follow the French doctrine, and would have been matched against the Germans in 1938. Again I have a longer post regarding this if you would like for me to copy it.

On the big picture we do agree however. The Czechoslovakian military would have had the ability to seriously harm the Germans in 1938 had conflict broken out. I do not believe the Czechoslovakians could have withstood an invasion for more than a month without direct ground support (which only the USSR was in a position to provide) but they would have not been pushed over. - James

Wed May 31 06:58:00 2000


 Anthony Aragon Russia helps Czechs in 38 (May, 17)
Anatoly re: Russia helps Czechs in 38 (May, 17)
 Mikhail re: Russia helps Czechs in 38 (May, 17)
 Amedeo Matteucci re: Russia helps Czechs in 38 (May, 21)
 James Quinn Please review the following scenario (May, 18)
 Anthony Aragon Bravo! Very interesting.  (-) (May, 18)
 Arashekino How about this scenario (May, 27)
Scott Fraser re: Czechoslovakia was no pushover (May, 29)
  •  James Quinn re: Czechoslovakia was no pushover (May, 31)
    Scott Fraser re: Czechoslovakia was no pushover (Jun, 4)
     James Quinn French invasion of Germany in 1938/39 (Jun, 6)
    Scott Fraser re: French invasion of Germany in 1938/39 (Jun, 6)
     James Quinn German invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1938 (Jun, 7)
  • James Quinn re: How about this scenario (May, 29)
     Arashekino Justicication for Pre-emptive strike (May, 29)

    Records: 15

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.