Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 Paul Lakowski:
re: Best tank of WW II criteria???

Operationally speaking the Sherman was the best tank cause it featured the best allround reliablity. When the T-34 started out they were loseing 60 out of every 100 tanks for every 100kms driven on marches alone. The German Pz III did much better than this marching over the same ground and distance losing about 1/3 tanks , so in the early war period the Pz-III was the best.

As the war progressed the German ammo manufacturing failed to keep pace and the replacement balloned into the Panther monster tank , which had appalling reliablity.

In the late war period Russian tank loses[read T-34] were around 13% for every 100km driven. But this was more of a reflection of the improved emphasis the Sovs placed on parts and the logistics tail of there combat units.Meanwhile Sherman reliablity topped all in no small part to design.

When you look @ the Tactical side, the most important quality is fire power as this is the mechanism that kills and thats what settles the battle.In terms of firepower the most important criteria is ROFor rate of fire.Obviously nothing can be stated as simplistic as that, cause theres a point where ROF can't make up for poor ammo penetration. This is why the failure of the German ammuntion concept -when the AP 40 shots disappeared - became one of there biggest failures.

In the intial stages the Pz-III was the best tactically due to its high rate of fire[ 2:1 against the french/ brits and 3-4:1 against the Russians]. By mid war the Panthers and Tigers featured lower ROFs while allies remained the same [ 8 rpm Germans Vs 3-4 rpm T-34s and 10-12 rpm for the Shermans ]. So the heavy armor and fire power worked against the Russians- to wars end ,but didn't work so well against the western allies.

Its hard to show just how important ROF is but if you take 2 tanks that are equal in all respects but blue out shoots red by 3:1 then- in an even battle -blue will inflict 10:1 kill ratios. Even out numbered, this kill ratio can be maintaned due to the smoke and fog of war.This allows better trained troops to section off large numbers into mini firefights near one on one.The weak point of the ROF argument is that it does require 'well trained troops' and to perserve those you do need good armor over enough of the front quadrant to allow the said 'well trained troops' to survive.

So I guess the bottom line is you can't pin down the best tank unless you have a proper strategy & tactics.If your forced to change mid stride, like the Germans you have to adjust your designs accordingly. Even the Poorly designed T-34 is the best tank at the end of the war cause the Sovs finally got there tank ; logistics and strategic situation right.

Tue May 30 07:59:56 2000


 Arashekino Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 27)
George Hogg re: Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 27)
 Arashekino re: how about criteria??? (May, 27)
Arashekino how about cost criteria??? (-) (May, 27)
clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 27)
 David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 28)
 clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
 David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
 clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
 clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
 David C. Clarke re: how about criteria/ Excellent Post (May, 29)
George Hogg re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
 clarence morgan samuels Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
 David C. Clarke re: Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
George W Hogg re: Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
Lee Dowd re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 2)
Lee Dowd Some Britt & US Crew Casulty figures? (Jun, 2)
Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
Lee Dowd Sorry about the multiple posts (May, 30)
 clarence morgan samuels An IS-2m for all my friends! (May, 29)
Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
 David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
 Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
 David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
 Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
Lee Dowd re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
George W Hogg re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
 Lee Dowd re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
Stephen Brezinski re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 27)
 Max re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
 Arashekino re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
 Arashekino What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
 clarence morgan samuels re: What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
 David C. Clarke re: What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
George Hogg re: 38t (May, 29)
 David C. Clarke re: 38t (May, 30)
  •  Paul Lakowski re: Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 30)
     Nick re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)
    Paul Lakowski re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)
     Amedeo Matteucci T-34 ROF (May, 30)
     Nick re: T-34 /85 ROF (May, 30)
    Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 30)
     Amedeo Matteucci re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Arashekino re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Arashekino re: T-34 ROF is it always better? (Jun, 4)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF is it always better? (Jun, 5)
     George W Hogg re: T-34 ROF (Jun, 2)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (Jun, 2)
    George W Hogg re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)
  • Records: 57

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.