Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


David C. Clarke:
re: how about criteria???

Hi again Mr. Samuels,
Great post, very enjoyable. Good point about the vastness of the Eastern Front and the need for large amounts of AFV's. I suppose the need is even greater if you're on the tail end of a 5-1 kill ratio.
I haven't read this book of Dunn's. Interestingly, there were many times when the German's used a similar method of repairing units; turning their surviving equipment over to a neighboring unit and withdrawing the personnel. I find it hard to believe that the Soviets also turned over crewmen to a neighboring unit just because their tanks survived a battle. What would the old unit use for cadre? But I'll not argue the point
as I have little information on it.
I do think your explanation of the "Guards" title is an oversimplification. A unit had to earn that title, not simply survive. In fact, I believe the Guards title was awarded a number of times to units that were virtually destroyed but had put up a damn good fight and achieved their objective.
Also, given the rigid standardization of Soviet tank production, I don't think you can claim "when the guards needed to be replenished they get better or equivalent AFV". Equivalent, probably, but not better. Afterall, what were the choices, a T-34/76 from Uralmash vs. one from another factory? The exception is of course the introduction of the T-34/85, a point we agree upon.
I said that the 35 ton tank was obselescent (wish I could spell that word right), not obsolete. And you're right, if a tank crew is lucky, all they have to do is maul the infantry. However, if the infantry have effective anti-tank guns, or attached SP tank destroyers, or if there are any 45 ton or 56 ton monsters lurking in the woods, then the Sherman or the T-34 is in for a hard time.
But you're absolutely right about the need for numbers and the need to control the battlefield after the battle. Can't argue with you there. And I still think we agree on most
points. I haven't heard you say yet what your personal mount would be. Come on, admit it, you know it would be an IS-2. Regards, David

Mon May 29 09:12:59 2000


 Arashekino Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 27)
George Hogg re: Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 27)
 Arashekino re: how about criteria??? (May, 27)
Arashekino how about cost criteria??? (-) (May, 27)
clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 27)
 David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 28)
 clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
 David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
 clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
  • David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     David C. Clarke re: how about criteria/ Excellent Post (May, 29)
    George Hogg re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
     David C. Clarke re: Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
    George W Hogg re: Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
    Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
    Lee Dowd re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 2)
    Lee Dowd Some Britt & US Crew Casulty figures? (Jun, 2)
    Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
    Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
    Lee Dowd Sorry about the multiple posts (May, 30)
     clarence morgan samuels An IS-2m for all my friends! (May, 29)
    Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
     David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
     Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
    Lee Dowd re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
    George W Hogg re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     Lee Dowd re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
  • Stephen Brezinski re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 27)
     Max re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
     Arashekino re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
     Arashekino What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
     David C. Clarke re: What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
    George Hogg re: 38t (May, 29)
     David C. Clarke re: 38t (May, 30)
     Paul Lakowski re: Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 30)
     Nick re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)
    Paul Lakowski re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)
     Amedeo Matteucci T-34 ROF (May, 30)
     Nick re: T-34 /85 ROF (May, 30)
    Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 30)
     Amedeo Matteucci re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Arashekino re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Arashekino re: T-34 ROF is it always better? (Jun, 4)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF is it always better? (Jun, 5)
     George W Hogg re: T-34 ROF (Jun, 2)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (Jun, 2)
    George W Hogg re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)

    Records: 57

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.