Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 clarence morgan samuels:
re: how about criteria???

"I believe that a 35 ton tank was obselecence by 1944, that only a 45 ton tank was capable of
carrying enough armor and gun to be survivable on the battlefield."

Without question the medium tank was vulnerable by '44. Perhaps even overly so. The eastern front was HUGE though. Large number of AFV were required to cover the whole span and replace losses. AFV and ordnance factories would never be able to build enough heavy AFV to supply all the fronts. To try to do so would be to throw away a chance at winning the war. What was required is enough AFV to be able to shoot up infantry. The T-34 did this just as well or better than a panther, hence the overriding need for medium AFV.

"I am unaware of any historical evidence that the Soviets only gave their newest tanks to veteran crews."

My source is "Hitler's Nemesis" by Walter S. Dunn, Jr. According to him in the chapter "Tank Crew Replacements and Training" The method of replacing losses was to witdraw the unit from combat, transfer all remaining tanks with crews to a neighbor, and to take the remaining crew and cadre to reform the unit. New tanks and crew filled out the unit.

Looking through the chapter "Refining the Tank Formations" and through the chapter "Tanks and Mechanized Artillery" in the book "The Soviet Economy and the Red Army 1930-1945" (Dunn) by observation you can see that the best vehicles were assigned to guards, mostly fresh out of combat rather than to a newly created unit.

I do say "mostly" as there are quite a few exceptions, but as a general principle good units that survive get a guards designation. Then when guards need to be refitted they get better or equivelent AFV. In time if a unit survived it would move up the ladder. If it got totaly wiped out it would have to start over as a freshly created unit, and in general newly created units did not get the cream of the production line. This is a difficult point to prove as exact selection of AFV is an unclear dynamic but in general ...

>>> 

Mon May 29 05:44:48 2000


 Arashekino Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 27)
George Hogg re: Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 27)
 Arashekino re: how about criteria??? (May, 27)
Arashekino how about cost criteria??? (-) (May, 27)
clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 27)
 David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 28)
 clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
 David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
  •  clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
    David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     David C. Clarke re: how about criteria/ Excellent Post (May, 29)
    George Hogg re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
     David C. Clarke re: Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
    George W Hogg re: Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
    Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
    Lee Dowd re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 2)
    Lee Dowd Some Britt & US Crew Casulty figures? (Jun, 2)
    Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
    Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
    Lee Dowd Sorry about the multiple posts (May, 30)
     clarence morgan samuels An IS-2m for all my friends! (May, 29)
    Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
     David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
     Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
    Lee Dowd re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
    George W Hogg re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     Lee Dowd re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
  • Stephen Brezinski re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 27)
     Max re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
     Arashekino re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
     Arashekino What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
     David C. Clarke re: What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
    George Hogg re: 38t (May, 29)
     David C. Clarke re: 38t (May, 30)
     Paul Lakowski re: Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 30)
     Nick re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)
    Paul Lakowski re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)
     Amedeo Matteucci T-34 ROF (May, 30)
     Nick re: T-34 /85 ROF (May, 30)
    Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 30)
     Amedeo Matteucci re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Arashekino re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Arashekino re: T-34 ROF is it always better? (Jun, 4)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF is it always better? (Jun, 5)
     George W Hogg re: T-34 ROF (Jun, 2)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (Jun, 2)
    George W Hogg re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)

    Records: 57

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.