Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 David C. Clarke:
re: how about criteria???

Hi Guys, It seems to me that crew survivability has to be considered when it comes to "cost". A
well trained crew has to be preserved even if the tank is knocked out. Well-trained crews are probably worth more to a country's war effort than the tank they man and are harder to produce.
Moreover, a well-armored and well-gunned tank will have more opportunities to inflict casualties on it's opponent. Folowing a strict "cost analysis" approach, the Tiger I should never have been built to the detriment of PZ. IV construction. But the Tiger and it's crews could survive longer than a Pz IV and the tank was capable of accomplishing more. The same anaylsis can be used in terms of the IS-2 vis-a-vis the T-34.
There is no perfect tank, there never will be one, there are too many factors to be considered: terrain, opposition, strategic vs. operational goals,etc. In my opinion, give me a
Tiger I in 1943 or a choice between an IS-2 and a Panther from 1944. Thanks for listening. DCC

Sun May 28 23:34:32 2000


 Arashekino Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 27)
George Hogg re: Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 27)
 Arashekino re: how about criteria??? (May, 27)
Arashekino how about cost criteria??? (-) (May, 27)
clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 27)
  •  David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 28)
     clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
    David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     David C. Clarke re: how about criteria/ Excellent Post (May, 29)
    George Hogg re: how about criteria??? (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
     David C. Clarke re: Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
    George W Hogg re: Only at Buy.com right? (May, 30)
    Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
    Lee Dowd re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 2)
    Lee Dowd Some Britt & US Crew Casulty figures? (Jun, 2)
    Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
    Lee Dowd Crew Casulties? was re: how about criteria??? (May, 30)
    Lee Dowd Sorry about the multiple posts (May, 30)
     clarence morgan samuels An IS-2m for all my friends! (May, 29)
    Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
     David C. Clarke re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
     Jorge Visca re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
    Lee Dowd re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
    George W Hogg re: how about criteria??? (May, 31)
     Lee Dowd re: how about criteria??? (Jun, 1)
  • Stephen Brezinski re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 27)
     Max re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
     Arashekino re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Depends on the intentions, region, etc.... (May, 28)
     Arashekino What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
     David C. Clarke re: What about the Light vehicles??? (May, 29)
    George Hogg re: 38t (May, 29)
     David C. Clarke re: 38t (May, 30)
     Paul Lakowski re: Best tank of WW II criteria??? (May, 30)
     Nick re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)
    Paul Lakowski re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)
     Amedeo Matteucci T-34 ROF (May, 30)
     Nick re: T-34 /85 ROF (May, 30)
    Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 30)
     Amedeo Matteucci re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Arashekino re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (May, 31)
     Arashekino re: T-34 ROF is it always better? (Jun, 4)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF is it always better? (Jun, 5)
     George W Hogg re: T-34 ROF (Jun, 2)
     Paul Lakowski re: T-34 ROF (Jun, 2)
    George W Hogg re: Difficult To Compare,But no doubt !! (May, 30)

    Records: 57

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.