| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
"Wasn't the Panther rather expensive and complex?"
Yes it was, on both accounts. It was also introduced (Ausf D) in a hasty manner leading to many engineering casualties.
"Was it really cost effective?"
There are arguments both ways. For a Wermacht at the end of a dwindling supply situation it makes some sense to make fewer vehicles as there is a shortage of trained crews, POL, and munitions to supply the mechanized forces. Such a high grade AFV takes advantage of a superior C3I system and trained crews that the Wermacht had in mid '43 when the PzKpfw V D was introduced.
Over the long run such a universal strategy was not to the advantage of the Wermacht and significantly contributed to their defeat.
On the other side of the coin building such a fine heavy AFV (Ausf G) that is built-to-last does an army little good if it is knocked out and over run before it recovers the cost invested in it. The Panther was death-on-a-stick against other AFV, but against infantry with flame throwers, demolition charges, and AT mines it was little better off than a Mk IV. If immobalized by an AT gun it can't spot it is just as stuck as a el-cheep-o AFV. Ground attack A/C have a better chance to spot and hit such a large AFV as well.
"I read another thread which said that in 42 T-34s were designed to last only through one or two battles. This does not seem like a cost effective solution in the short run."
Actualy this is exactly what the Soviets needed at the time, and as on overall strategy it is the one that the Wermacht should have used from the start. The Soviets used it the whole war and it served them well. Stalin was correct in saying "Quantity has a quality all of its own."
If the statistical life expectation of an AFV is only six months any design features built that lasts longer than that is a waste of effort. The Soviet concept was to replace worn or knocked out vehicles with new ones. This allowed them to almost entirely eliminate the repair and spare ...
Sun May 28 20:50:26 2000
| Records: 57 |
| Russian Military Zone | Soviet Artillery 1920-1945 | Virtual Library |
| Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! | Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. | Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government. |