Don Caldwell:
The data are posted....
...on the JG 26 Home Page (http://jg26.cjb.net/) in a table titled, "Luftwaffe Losses by Theater: Sept 1943 - Oct 1944". The table is not as clear as I would like, for which I apologize, but it bears study by everyone reading this thread. The numbers quoted by Christer are entirely correct. During the tabulated period, during which the Luftwaffe totally lost control of the air over its own homeland, the ratio of fighters lost in the West to the average operational strength of the units in the West was 10.8/1; the same ratio in the East was 5.8/1. There were 6.4 fighters lost in the West for every one lost in the East. Data on losses per sortie would be very valuable, but I haven't found enough yet to post.
There is ample contemporary evidence that the Luftwaffe considered the West to be the tougher theater. I don't mean post-war memoirs or the opinions of pro-Western historians, but documents from the period; these are primarily intercepted radio messages from the Ultra series, although there are some pertinent documents in the Bundesarchiv. Examples: (1) The office of the General der Jagdflieger urged the fighter schools to send their poorer graduates east for seasoning, rather than directly into the meat grinder of th Reichsverteidigung; the Eastern Front was to be considered a large OTU. (2) Every Jagdgruppe in the east had to send one Staffel west in the spring of 1944, to strengthen the Reich defenses. These were replaced by new Staffeln that were given the old designations, but were filled with green pilots straight from the OTUs. As far as I can tell, this transfer made no appreciable difference to the air wars in either theater.
Was the Western front harder on German pilots simply because of the numerical superiority of the USAAF, or did qualitative factors (equipment, pilot skills) come into play? This is a complicated question, and I think Christer and I disagree here to some degree, but the fact remains that the Western theater was tougher -- the numbers show it.
Sun May 28 20:44:58 2000
Max
Luftwaffe attrition rate in the East vs. West (May, 26)
Stephen Brezinski
re: Luftwaffe attrition rate in the East vs. West (May, 26)
Scott Fraser
re: Luftwaffe attrition rate in the East vs. West (May, 27)
Stephen Brezinski
re: You speak a fair (not convincing) argument... (May, 27)
Scott Fraser
re: You speak a fair (not convincing) argument... (May, 28)
Arashekino
If your so smart why can't you answer my ? (May, 28)
Max
re: If your so smart why can't you answer my ? (May, 28)
- Don Caldwell
The data are posted.... (May, 28)
Christer Bergstrom
Don Caldwell's JG 26 book is highly recommendable (May, 28)
Max
My amateurish calculation (May, 28)
Christer Bergstrom
Aircraft losses (May, 28)
D�nes Bern�d
re: 'Dry' data (May, 29)
Sven
re: Not correct (May, 27)
Mark D.
re: Luftwaffe attrition rate in the East vs. West (May, 26)
Scott Fraser
re: Luftwaffe attrition rate in the East vs. West (May, 27)
George Hogg
re: Luftwaffe attrition on airfields (May, 27)
Scott Fraser
re: Luftwaffe attrition on airfields (May, 28)
George Hogg
re: Luftwaffe attrition on airfields (May, 28)
Max
re: Luftwaffe attrition rate in the East vs. West (May, 27)
Christer Bergstrom
Comparison of the air wars in the East and in "the West" (May, 27)
Christer Bergstrom
Names & publications (May, 27)
Lev
re: Luftwaffe attrition rate in the East vs. West (May, 27)
Christer Bergstrom
re: Luftwaffe attrition rate in the East vs. West (May, 27)
Max
Well done Christer!!!!!!!! (May, 28)
TIM
re: Well done Christer!!!!!!!! (May, 28)
clarence morgan samuels
So what are you trying to say ??? (May, 28)
TIM
re: So what are you trying to say ??? (May, 29)
Arashekino
re: So what are you trying to say ??? (May, 31)
clarence morgan samuels
re: So what are you trying to say ??? (May, 31)
George Hogg
re: Point well made (May, 28)
Juha
re: Well done Christer!!!!!!!! (May, 30)
Christer Bergstrom
Luftwaffe unit losses on the Eastern Front, month by month (May, 31)
Christer Bergstrom
re: Luftwaffe unit losses on the Eastern Front, month by month (May, 31)