Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Scott Fraser:
re: Myths and misconceptions

I am confused:

"The Soviets never used the P-39 as a ground attack aircraft". It was used as such in the Pacific and considered useful in that role and against shipping I believe. The lack of high altititude performance was the main reason it was disliked by the Western allies as a fighter."

Okay, I'll accept that I should have qualified the sentence by saying "the Soviets never used it. . ." I wasn't aware that the USAAF had used it in the Pacific as a ground-attack aircraft. You are correct in that the Americans and British had no use for the P-39 as a fighter because of it's lack of high-altitude performance. However the VVS pilots appreciated it greatly because: 1.) it had excellent performance below 5000ft; 2.) Soviet pilots liked the 20mm cannon, and especialy the 37mm cannon on some of the aircraft delivered. They also considered the .50cal as an excellent weapon, which it was. 3.) It had a centrally mounted armament suite, as opposed to wing-mounted weapons, which Soviet pilots felt diluted the weight of fire; 4.) the engine's position behind the pilot made it more likely the engine would get killed before the pilot; 5.) It had a reliable radio, a luxury in 1943 when the Airacobra made it's d�but.

Now my question:
That may also be the source of the confusion regarding its role on the Eastern front. i.e. Westerners didn't think it was any good as a fighter but made a good ground attack plane so that must be the way the Soviets used it especially given their emphasis on ground support.

Are you speculating on how the myth that the VVS used the P-39 as a ground-attack aircraft arose, or are you stating that they did use it as a ground-attack aircraft, because that's all the Americans could find to do with it, and because the VVS was big on ground attack? Please, the ground-attack aircraft used by the VVS, in order of appearance, were primarily the R-Zet, the I-153, the I-16, and the Il-2. The Sturmovik was introduced during the battle for Stalingrad, and by the time of Kursk was rapidly replacing other aircraft in that role. By 1944 virtually all VVS ShAP were equipped with Sturmoviki.

Sat May 27 02:38:09 2000


 Stefan WHERE WAS THE RUSSIAN STRATEGIC BOMBER FORCE IN WW2 (May, 18)
Scott Fraser re: WHERE WAS THE RUSSIAN STRATEGIC BOMBER FORCE IN WW2 (May, 18)
 AndyW re: WHERE WAS THE RUSSIAN STRATEGIC BOMBER FORCE IN WW2 (May, 18)
Scott Fraser re: B-25s, A-20s, Il-4s (May, 19)
Stephen Brezinski re: WHERE WAS THE RUSSIAN STRATEGIC BOMBER FORCE IN WW2 (May, 18)
 Max re: WHERE WAS THE RUSSIAN STRATEGIC BOMBER FORCE IN WW2 (May, 19)
Stephen Brezinski re: Bombing and such.... (May, 19)
Christer Bergstrom Eastern Front Air War (May, 25)
Christer Bergstrom URL (May, 25)
 Max Question the Christer Bergstrom (May, 25)
Christer Bergstrom Black Cross/Red Star; Cocarde and White Star... (May, 26)
Stephen Brezinski re: Sounds like I stand corrected.... (May, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Myths and misconceptions (May, 19)
 Juha re: Myths and misconceptions (May, 19)
Scott Fraser re: Myths and misconceptions (May, 20)
Christer Bergstrom Aircraft loss statistics & ace victories on the Eastern Front (May, 25)
Lee Dowd re: Myths and misconceptions (May, 26)
  • Scott Fraser re: Myths and misconceptions (May, 27)
    Lee Dowd re: Myths and misconceptions (May, 30)
    Scott Fraser re: Myths and misconceptions (May, 30)
  •  Mikhail Don't forget Economics  (May, 19)
    Jari Lievonen Bombing Helsinki in 1944 (May, 18)
    Sami re: Bombing Helsinki in 1944 (May, 19)
    Lee Dowd re: Bombing Helsinki in 1944 (May, 26)
    Robert A. Mosher re: RUSSIAN BOMBER FORCE IN WW2: Great Thread! (May, 20)
     Stefan Thanks for a VERY informative thread!  (May, 20)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust ADD = Soviet Long-range aviation (May, 21)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: ADD = Soviet Long-range aviation, addition (May, 21)
    Christer Bergstrom ADD bomber missions (May, 23)
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: ADD bomber missions (May, 23)

    Records: 30

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.