Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Anatoly:
re: Icebreaker : Who Started the Second World War?

Hello
I think "Suvorov" is not historian but very good propagandist on the service of her Majesty. By the way his pseudonym is most provocative and scandal. Real Suvorov was very famous person in History of Russia. Name Suvorov is a name of Glory.
What do you say about such man who will choose such pseudonym: Churchill or Nelson or Wellington or Cromwell. I think it is most dishonest way. And "Suvorov" is going on this way. Those who change his name for money or for power have a deal with devil I suppouse. Lenin refused his fathers name Ulianov and became to be Lenin. Trotsky refused his fathers name. Stalin refused his fathers name. They sold his soul to devil on such way.
Jisus was tempted by devil to refuse his FATHERS name.
But enought such Orthodox mistics.
I think it is too simple to discuss arguments in "Suvorovs" book. Really how can I beleave Stalin did the plan of all WW2. Also I do not think Stalin, Soviets, Russians was planning to attack Germany. It is too simple to discuss this topic. Why Stalin did not give order to advance in may 1940? Or anywhen else. It was nessesary to attack but anyway it was not done. Why? Why Russia had a trade with Germany. Only becouse of noone wanted a war. Also Stalin did not want big war. I think it is clear for those who red history.
Who started WW2? Those who became to shoot in 1 september 1939. Russia became to advance 17 september 1939. There was not any government in Poland in this day. Warshawa was sorrounded. Lwow was surrounded. It was nessesary to protect Russia(Ucraine ond Belorussia) so it was done with Russian army. It was not war against Poland becouse of Russian army did not go into Polish lands. I think it was moral desision. Noone have a rights to judje such deed. Sometimes they say about sicret protokols signed by Stalin. I do not think sicret protocols is important thing. I can proof this point with next evidences.
1.Stalin was not chief of Soviet state. Kalinin was chief of Soviet State. So Stalins sign had no justis power. May be for someone it is not important. But I am citizen of Russia and it is most important for me.
2. It is not right way to discuss only sicret protocols about relationship betwin Russia and Germany. I think it is possible only if compare with ALL sicret protocols. For example where is protocols betwin England, France, Poland and Germany about dividing Chechoslovakia.
Another example where is protocols betwin England, France and Germany about allys did not attack Germany in 1939 till may 1940. And so on.
Where is sicret protocols betwin US and Jupan.
So.
I think it is nessesary to be objactive. It is very pity Cold war still exist in the books of such "Suvorov".
good luck

Thu May 25 09:53:17 2000


Scott Schaffer Icebreaker : Who Started the Second World War? (May, 25)
 Leonid re: Icebreaker : review these RMZ threads (May, 25)
 Scott Schaffer Ouch! Forget I said a word, folks. The above post never happened. n/t (May, 25)
Andreas Seidel Too late now! You should have thought of that before!! :-) n/t (May, 25)
  • Anatoly re: Icebreaker : Who Started the Second World War? (May, 25)
     Arashekino Very Intersting perspective!!! (May, 25)
    Anatoly re: Very Intersting perspective!!! (May, 25)
    Henrik Krog As to Hitler and Schiklgruber (May, 25)
     Max re: Icebreaker : Who Started the Second World War? (May, 25)
    Andreas Seidel Where can I buy the book(s) anyway? (May, 25)
     Arashekino Sorry but the cold war smolders on! (May, 25)
    Lee Dowd re: Sorry but the cold war smolders on! (May, 25)
     Nick re: No NATO or UN!! (May, 26)
     Mikhail re: Icebreaker : Who Started the Second World War? (May, 26)
    Andreas Seidel re: Icebreaker : Who Started the Second World War? (May, 25)
    Lee Dowd A third possibility was re: Icebreaker : Who Started the Second World War? (May, 25)
     Nick re: A third possibility was re: Icebreaker : Who Started ... (May, 25)
     Andreas Seidel Fourth Possibility (May, 25)
    Lee Dowd re: Fourth Possibility (May, 25)
    George Hogg re: A third possibility was re: Icebreaker : Who Started ... (May, 26)
     Nick re: Tukachevsky (May, 26)
     Mikhail re: Tukachevsky (May, 26)
     Nick re: Old Bolshevists? FEAR IS WHAT STALIN NEEDED!! (May, 26)
  • Records: 23

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.