Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 Max:
re: sherman under-rated?

I sincerely admire the courage of the colonel Dmitry Loza and in no way am trying to question his accounts. He is a great hero but compared to other accounts of the Sherman performance in the Soviet and Russian literature, I can't really help asking myself if in this publication (I may be wrong but I doubt that it has ever been published in Russia), which is designed entirely for the western reader, he tells what an American ear wants to hear. Indeed there is much propaganda in the negative feeling Russian soldiers allegedly had about lend-lease tanks. But I'm asking myself to what degree this commercial publication, which is supposed to appeal to the Western reader, could be taken at its face value.

Also, given the experience on the Western front, where Armor divisions, couldn't really stand their ground against Panzer divisions without total air cover, some of this (like too high a silhouette, gas engine, narrow tracks, thin and poorly sloped armor etc.) must be true. And another thing, lend-lease tanks constituted only a small percentage in the overall Soviet tank force, and couldn't have really had any serious impact on the outcome.

Regards

Fri May 19 12:48:56 2000


 Mark Degnan U.S. Arrmor Inferiority ? (May, 15)
 Anthony Aragon re: U.S. Arrmor Inferiority ? (May, 16)
 Nick re: U.S. Armor Inferiority ? (May, 16)
Scott Fraser re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 16)
 Nick re: One Less Crew Member!! A disadvantage? (May, 16)
Scott Fraser re: One Less Crew Member!! A disadvantage (May, 17)
 Nick re: T34/85,first REAL improvment (May, 17)
 Valera Potapov re: T34/85,first REAL improvment (May, 18)
 Valera Potapov re: One Less Crew Member!! A disadvantage? (May, 18)
 ... Was the TC also the gunner or the loader? (May, 26)
Lynn Tharpe re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 16)
 Mark Degnan Korean Experiences? (May, 16)
 Anthony Aragon re: Korean Experiences? (May, 17)
 Nick re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 17)
Juha re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 17)
 Anthony Aragon re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 17)
 Lee Dowd re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 18)
 Aragon I did a little research (May, 24)
Victor re: Korean Experiences? (May, 22)
Juha re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 17)
Paul Lakowski re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 17)
 Samuel BHN? (May, 18)
Lee Dowd re: BHN? (May, 18)
Lee Dowd re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 18)
 Stephen Brezinski re: sherman under-rated (May, 19)
  •  Max re: sherman under-rated? (May, 19)
    George Hogg re: sherman under-rated? (May, 21)
  •  clarence morgan samuels re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 27)

    Records: 28

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.