Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Lee Dowd:
re: U.S. Armor Inferiority

>The 85mm M44 gun was easily as good as the 76.2mm L/54 gun of the later Shermans,

Part of the problem here is that the US viewed tanks as infantry support weapons and the 75 had a nice HE round. Tank destroyers were suppose to fight tanks. The ergonomics and communications capability of the Sherman also gave it an edge in those areas. Most sources also claim it was more reliable.

>Pershing, which never saw combat in WW2

The Pershing did see combat a number were lost and they were credited with a number of German tanks destroyed. However I believe the Pershing had some reliability problems.

>As for armour, there is no contest.

The T-34, Sherman, and Pershing for that matter were functionally equivalant in terms of armor. Given the opposing weapons there was little or no practicle difference. For that reason some have argued that a Sherman with a 90mm would have been better than the Pershing.

> The Sherman was a big, square, thin-walled armoured box full of gasoline, and richly deserved the name "Ronson"

This has been pretty well discredited. From studies I have seen reported there wasn't much more of a tendency of the Sherman to burn than other tanks. What there was was due in large part to American tankers stuffing extra rounds in every available space.

Thu May 18 22:41:53 2000


 Mark Degnan U.S. Arrmor Inferiority ? (May, 15)
 Anthony Aragon re: U.S. Arrmor Inferiority ? (May, 16)
 Nick re: U.S. Armor Inferiority ? (May, 16)
Scott Fraser re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 16)
 Nick re: One Less Crew Member!! A disadvantage? (May, 16)
Scott Fraser re: One Less Crew Member!! A disadvantage (May, 17)
 Nick re: T34/85,first REAL improvment (May, 17)
 Valera Potapov re: T34/85,first REAL improvment (May, 18)
 Valera Potapov re: One Less Crew Member!! A disadvantage? (May, 18)
 ... Was the TC also the gunner or the loader? (May, 26)
Lynn Tharpe re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 16)
 Mark Degnan Korean Experiences? (May, 16)
 Anthony Aragon re: Korean Experiences? (May, 17)
 Nick re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 17)
Juha re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 17)
 Anthony Aragon re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 17)
 Lee Dowd re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 18)
 Aragon I did a little research (May, 24)
Victor re: Korean Experiences? (May, 22)
Juha re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 17)
Paul Lakowski re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 17)
 Samuel BHN? (May, 18)
Lee Dowd re: BHN? (May, 18)
  • Lee Dowd re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 18)
     Stephen Brezinski re: sherman under-rated (May, 19)
     Max re: sherman under-rated? (May, 19)
    George Hogg re: sherman under-rated? (May, 21)
     clarence morgan samuels re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 27)
  • Records: 28

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.