Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Scott Fraser:
re: Your grandpa could have been .....

The suggestion that Japan be blockaded and forced to surrender after a protracted seige was not a suggestion the Americans would accept. Firstly, the very bitter fighting on Okinawa and Iwo Jima was fresh in their minds, fighting which showed the fanatical determination of the Japanese to resist any invasion and the complete willingness to suffer death before considering surrender to the enemy. The US suffered very heavy casualties during the invasion of those small islands, and it was anticipated that the number of casualties which might be suffered in invading the Home Islands would be proportionate. You are correctin your suggestion that Japan was doomed if it could be beseiged, but again, the US Navy's experience in the Philippines, at Iwo Jima and Okinawa was very bitter. The US lost many, many ships to Kamikaze during those actions, which were fairly short in comparison with how long a full-blown seige of Japan might last. Throughout the period of blockade, American (and British) ships would be within range of Japanese aircraft, and there was no shortage of bombs, aircraft, or pilots willing to dive on the Americans. It would have been a very costly adventure. The choice of whether to drop the Bomb, even if they had known clearly how devastating it could be, which they did not, was a very simple choice to make.

Thu May 18 08:30:46 2000


TIM American history says,because of A-bomb,Japan ... (May, 17)
 Nick re: Kamikaze!! (May, 17)
 Anthony Aragon re: Kamikaze!! (May, 18)
 Max re: American history says,because of A-bomb,Japan ... (May, 17)
Robert A. Mosher re: American history says,because of A-bomb,Japan ... (May, 17)
 Kirill Bulatkin Your grandpa could have been ..... (May, 17)
Mikhail re: Your grandpa could have been ..... (May, 17)
Zbynio I agree with everyone here, on this subject. (May, 18)
 Anthony Aragon Why don't Americans apologize to Mexico? (May, 18)
 Zbynio re: Why don't Americans apologize to Mexico? (May, 18)
 Stephen Brezinski re: Why don't Mexicans apologize to Indians (Native Mexican citizens)? (May, 18)
TIM re: Your grandpa could have been ..... (May, 18)
Bob Potter Why two cities? (May, 18)
Scott Fraser re: Why two cities (May, 18)
  • Scott Fraser re: Your grandpa could have been ..... (May, 18)
  • Scott Schaffer That reminds me. Weren't the Russians planning.... (May, 18)
     Anthony Aragon re: That reminds me. Weren't the Russians planning.... (May, 18)
     Alex Wood re: That reminds me. Weren't the Russians planning.... (May, 24)
    Scott Fraser In Total War, there are no civilians. n/t (-) (May, 18)
    George Hogg re: The bomb was built to drop on germany!! (May, 18)
     Anthony Aragon Check out anime movie "Fireflies grave"  (May, 18)
     Nick re: To Discourage Soviets!!! (May, 18)
    Zbynio In EVERY war there are civilians (-) (May, 18)
     AndyW re: In Total War, there are no civilians.  (May, 18)
    Zbynio I am not so sure. (May, 18)
     Arashekino Sorry history shows it is not true! (May, 24)
     Daniel Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Vietnam, Bagdad, Belgrad ... (May, 18)
     Zbynio re: Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Vietnam, Bagdad, Belgrad ... (May, 18)
     Mikhail re: Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Vietnam, Bagdad, Belgrad ... (May, 19)
     Nick re: "The pot don't call the kettle black" (May, 19)
    Zbynio Americans-the bad guys, Russians-the cuties. (May, 19)
     Mikhail re: Americans-the bad guys, Russians-the cuties. (May, 19)
     Zbynio re: Americans-the bad guys, Russians-the cuties. (May, 19)
     Mikhail re: Americans-the bad guys, Russians-the cuties. (May, 19)
     Valera Potapov re: Americans-the bad guys, Russians-the cuties. (May, 20)
    Zbynio re: Americans-the bad guys, Russians-the cuties. (May, 20)
     Max Why won't you cool out, Zbynio. Why this attack on poor ... (May, 19)
    Zbynio To Max. Only. (-) (May, 19)
    Zbynio To Max.  (May, 19)
     Max re: To Max.  (May, 19)
    Zbynio re: To Max.  (May, 19)
     Valera Potapov re: To Max.  (May, 20)
    Zbynio re: To Valera (May, 20)
     Valera Potapov re: To Valera (May, 20)
     Daniel re: To Valera (May, 20)
     Valera Potapov re: To Valera (May, 21)
     Daniel re: To Valera (May, 21)
     Valera Potapov re: To Valera (May, 21)
     Mikhail Lets take American History (May, 21)
     Daniel re: To Valera (May, 23)
    Daniel re: Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Vietnam, Bagdad, Belgrad ... (May, 20)
     Brian re: Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Vietnam, Bagdad, Belgrad ... (May, 21)
     Daniel re: Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Vietnam, Bagdad, Belgrad ... (May, 23)
     Patrick H Echelon (May, 23)
    Daniel re: Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Vietnam, Bagdad, Belgrad ... (May, 20)

    Records: 55

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.