Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Kit Hildreth:
re:"The US Army won the war."

Just got routed to this forum via the Tankers.net! Nice to see different subjects being aired. Hailing from Blighty myself, I can only echo your sentiments as to the American attitude towards the participation of others in WW2. I was not aware that the History curricula in US schools were equally as parochial and one sided as the opinions of the General Populous.Did they really spend as much as two days on the Russo-German War?! When I was a nipper during the Jurassic era(!) we got only 1 lesson, wherein I caused a sensation by being the only pupil who knew the name of a German General(Von Paulus) other than Rommel! Or that there was even a war in Russia at all! I had to learn - sorry, I'll rephrase that, relearn - accurate history outside the classroom. So it's not so unusual; we Brits are almost as bad. But the difference is I think is in how all other viewpoints are ruthlessly weeded out leading to an ignorant populous with no idea of the world outside America, or that anyone else counts. The Romans were much the same and so were we during our heydey as were the Germans during their hegemony in Eastern Europe/Russia. Concur wholeheartedly with your postulate that the failure to drive upon Moscow in late-July, early August was the death knell of not merely Barbarossa, but German survival in Russia. A book called "Hitlers' Panzers East" elaborates upon this theme in great detail. The book is by R.F.H Stolfi and is published by The University of Oklahoma Press: the publisher of "Panzer Battls" by F.W von Mellenthin who also had a hand in the Stolfi work apparently.

Wed May 17 20:18:33 2000


 Nick 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 10)
 Tommy Thats right (-) (May, 10)
George Hogg re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 10)
 Nick re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
Scott Fraser re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
Mikhail re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
TS re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
George Hogg re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
Scott Fraser re: The US Army won the war. (May, 12)
 Max re: The US Army won the war. (May, 12)
 George Hogg re: British wit (May, 13)
 Alex Wood re: British wit (May, 13)
 Zbynio re: British codebrakers ????? (May, 13)
 Alex Wood re: British codebrakers ????? (May, 14)
Kit Hildreth re: British wit (May, 17)
  • Kit Hildreth re:"The US Army won the war." (May, 17)
  • Scott Schaffer Whats more.... (May, 12)
    Bob Potter In Defense of Stephen Ambrose -- and another thought (May, 13)
     Stephen Brezinski re: Lets look at the war as a whole... (May, 12)
     Nick re: Lets look at the war as a whole... (May, 12)
     Mark Degnan A questions of time... (May, 12)
    Zbynio where is victory there is many fathers (-) (May, 12)
     Stephen Brezinski re: Well said.... (May, 13)
     Max Contribution to Victory (May, 13)
    Scott Schaffer Trucks (May, 13)
     Max Trucks were not decisive!!!!!  (May, 13)
    Bob Potter Boot leather and Rusian Spam (May, 13)
    Shveik re: Boot leather and Rusian Spam (May, 14)
     Max Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
    Bob re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
     Max re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
    George Hogg re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
    Bob Wanted to, but couldn�t! (May, 15)
     Anthony Aragon Japs?  (May, 16)
     Bob Oops! (May, 17)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 29)
     Stephen Brezinski re: Trucks were decisive!!!!!  (May, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 14)
    TIM re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 15)
     clarence morgan samuels Lets hear it for TEAM effort. (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Trucks (May, 29)

    Records: 43

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.