Juha :
re: Soviet Tank Strength
Hello Anthony
I don't have my references here in my work but
1) Some PzDs had some Pz Is in their PzRgts at the beginning of the Oper. Barbarossa and they were counted as tanks. In some PzDs there were also some Pz Is and IIs in their Pioneer Battallions and I can't remember if these were caunted as tanks or not.
2)I'd say that if the StuGs were counted as tanks they'd be mediums.
3) Germans didn't have any tanks in their Motorized or Infantry Divs at that stage. But some of these divs used later few of the captured Russian tanks. I can't say when this happened first time. And at least one Inf.D (196th ?, can't remember the number) had arty battallion equipped with unofficial SP guns made in their own workshops. They were built on the captured British Mk VI light tanks and if some Russians fought against these and reported that they had fought against German tanks that was perfectly acceptable.
4) At least one Flamethrower tank unit used modified ex-French CharB tanks at the beginning of the Barbarossa. There were other units with ex French tanks, one of which operated in the Northern Finland, but I tended to think that these came along only later, but I might be wrong. BTW some of the Recon Battalions of the PzDs had ex-French Pankhard armoured cars (for example that of the 7th PzD).
5) Replacements were a problem but a few hundred tanks were given as replacements during the 1941, I think.
6) I think that the Germans melted down most of the Russian tanks they captured. So they got high quality steel from them. Some captured Russian tanks were used as gun tractors, some were sold to the Germany's allies.
7)I think that a totally beaten army is a good object of research because its surviving papers would fell to the victors and so are more easily open to the researchers than otherwise would be.
So even if many German generals claimed after the war that they were beaten only by the numbers and because Mr. Hitler didn't allow them to do the right things we can check at least some of strength figures from the documents and came up to our own conclusions. And of course we much be very critical about what the Germans said about the stregth figures or the losses of their opponents. And of course we ought to check always for what purpose certain figures were collected for. As I wrote I can't remember if those Pz Is and IIs in the pioneer battallions of the some PzDs were counted as tanks or not but that made no difference to a Russian AT-rifleman. To him they were tanks.
Greetings
Juha
Wed May 17 15:22:30 2000
Anthony Aragon
I was wondering if there is a way to know how many Tanks the ... (May, 13)
Craig Crofoot
Soviet Tank Strength (May, 13)
Anthony Aragon
re: Soviet Tank Strength (May, 13)
Valera Potapov
re: Soviet Tank Strength (May, 14)
Anthony Aragon
re: Soviet Tank Strength (May, 14)
Max
re: Soviet Tank Strength (May, 14)
Anthony Aragon
re: Soviet Tank Strength (May, 16)
Juha
re: Soviet Tank Strength (May, 16)
Anthony Aragon
re: Soviet Tank Strength (May, 16)
Juha
re: Soviet Tank Strength (May, 17)
Max
re: Soviet Tank Strength (May, 16)
Samuel
2nd categoy? (May, 14)