Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Scott Fraser:
re: U.S. Armor Inferiority

I would agree. The T-34 was a formidable tank, IMHO the best tank of WW2. It was fast, very well armoured, had excellent cross-country performance, a reliable and indestructible Diesel engine, and with the T-34/43 (which actually appeared in 1942) the new turret addressed the most serious problem it had as a combat vehicle, poor visibility and very cramped and uncomfortable quarters. In terms of armour penetration, the 76.2mm M39/F-32 gun was much better than the 75mm fitted to the bulk of the Shermans, and on a par with the 76mm gun fitted to the Shermans in 1944, three years after the T-34 first appeared with this gun.

The T-34/85 was that much better. The 85mm M44 gun was easily as good as the 76.2mm L/54 gun of the later Shermans, and perhaps as good as the 90mm used on the M26. At the same time the T-34/85 was faster and more maneuverable that the Pershing, which never saw combat in WW2. The Pershing was essentially a postwar tank, a contemporary of the IS-3 and the Centurion, and was discarded quickly in favour of the M47 and then M48. The Americans were a step behind the Soviets in tank development for many years.

As for armour, there is no contest. The T-34 was much better protected than the Sherman, both in terms of thickness and design. The Sherman was a big, square, thin-walled armoured box full of gasoline, and richly deserved the name "Ronson" which American troops gave it. It was easy meat even for the 50mm PaK 38, whereas the Germans scrambled to develop the 75mm PaK 40 in order to combat the T-34.

No mention of the KV? There is an apocryphal story of how a single KV-2 held up two Panzer divisions on the road to Leningrad. The KV was slow and somewhat cumbersome, but it was very heavily armoured and gave the Germans severe problems when they ran up against them. The only weapon they =had which could deal with it was the 88mm Flak 18, which had proved its worth as an anti-tank gun in North Africa. The problem was, the Flak 18 belonged ...

>>> 

Tue May 16 15:08:20 2000


 Mark Degnan U.S. Arrmor Inferiority ? (May, 15)
 Anthony Aragon re: U.S. Arrmor Inferiority ? (May, 16)
 Nick re: U.S. Armor Inferiority ? (May, 16)
  • Scott Fraser re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 16)
     Nick re: One Less Crew Member!! A disadvantage? (May, 16)
    Scott Fraser re: One Less Crew Member!! A disadvantage (May, 17)
     Nick re: T34/85,first REAL improvment (May, 17)
     Valera Potapov re: T34/85,first REAL improvment (May, 18)
     Valera Potapov re: One Less Crew Member!! A disadvantage? (May, 18)
     ... Was the TC also the gunner or the loader? (May, 26)
    Lynn Tharpe re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 16)
     Mark Degnan Korean Experiences? (May, 16)
     Anthony Aragon re: Korean Experiences? (May, 17)
     Nick re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 17)
    Juha re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 17)
     Anthony Aragon re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 17)
     Lee Dowd re: EVIDENCE?? (May, 18)
     Aragon I did a little research (May, 24)
    Victor re: Korean Experiences? (May, 22)
    Juha re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 17)
    Paul Lakowski re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 17)
     Samuel BHN? (May, 18)
    Lee Dowd re: BHN? (May, 18)
    Lee Dowd re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 18)
     Stephen Brezinski re: sherman under-rated (May, 19)
     Max re: sherman under-rated? (May, 19)
    George Hogg re: sherman under-rated? (May, 21)
     clarence morgan samuels re: U.S. Armor Inferiority (May, 27)
  • Records: 28

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.