Scott Fraser:
re: Trucks were decisive � NOT!
You are correct, of course, that all of the Allies contributed to the defeat of Germany, and to squabble about who gets more credit is foolish. However, it is said "History is the Propaganda of the Victors", and in this case we have many victors, and many histories, in several languages. It is no more correct for the Russians to dismiss the Lend-Lease contribution as meaningless than it is for the Americans to insist that without their handouts the USSR would have surrendered.
English-language histories are full of such assertions, stemming largely from wartime American propaganda, where Lend-Lease was seen as doing something to help defeat the Nazis, at a time when there were no American troops involved anywhere outside the Pacific. As a result, too many people come through the school system in the United States (and Canada) believing that Lend-Lease was decisive in defeating Germany, without ever taking the trouble to look into the reality of the Great Patriotic War or to examine the economic and social aspects of that struggle.
So, I will agree that all the Allies (and the USSR was an Ally!) contributed. However, I will not agree that Lend-Lease was decisive in any way, nor will I accept that the American contribution of money and machinery can be equated to the Soviet contribution of blood and sacrifice. They could have delivered 30 million tanks and 30 million airplanes, and I would still insist that is poor trade for 30 million lives.
� ���, �������� ���� ������ ������� ����, � ������ �������. �� ���������, �������, ��� ��� ��������� ������������ � ������ ��� ��������, � ��� �������� �������� � ���, ���� ������ ������ �����. �� ��������, ��� �������� � ��� ���������� �����������, � � ���� ������ � ��� ����� ����������� � ����� ��������, � ������ ������. ��� �� ���������� ���� ������� ������� ����-��� ��������������, ��� ������������ ����������, ��� ��� ���� �������� �������� ���������� ����� ���������.
���������-��������� ������� ������ ������ ...
>>>
Mon May 15 13:28:00 2000
Nick
8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 10)
Tommy
Thats right (-) (May, 10)
George Hogg
re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 10)
Nick
re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
Scott Fraser
re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
Mikhail
re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
TS
re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
George Hogg
re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
Scott Fraser
re: The US Army won the war. (May, 12)
Max
re: The US Army won the war. (May, 12)
George Hogg
re: British wit (May, 13)
Alex Wood
re: British wit (May, 13)
Zbynio
re: British codebrakers ????? (May, 13)
Alex Wood
re: British codebrakers ????? (May, 14)
Kit Hildreth
re: British wit (May, 17)
Kit Hildreth
re:"The US Army won the war." (May, 17)
Scott Schaffer
Whats more.... (May, 12)
Bob Potter
In Defense of Stephen Ambrose -- and another thought (May, 13)
Stephen Brezinski
re: Lets look at the war as a whole... (May, 12)
Nick
re: Lets look at the war as a whole... (May, 12)
Mark Degnan
A questions of time... (May, 12)
Zbynio
where is victory there is many fathers (-) (May, 12)
Stephen Brezinski
re: Well said.... (May, 13)
Max
Contribution to Victory (May, 13)
Scott Schaffer
Trucks (May, 13)
Max
Trucks were not decisive!!!!! (May, 13)
Bob Potter
Boot leather and Rusian Spam (May, 13)
Shveik
re: Boot leather and Rusian Spam (May, 14)
Max
Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
Bob
re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
Max
re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
George Hogg
re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
Bob
Wanted to, but couldn�t! (May, 15)
Anthony Aragon
Japs? (May, 16)
Bob
Oops! (May, 17)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 29)
Stephen Brezinski
re: Trucks were decisive!!!!! (May, 14)
Scott Fraser
re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 14)
TIM
re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 14)
- Scott Fraser
re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 15)
clarence morgan samuels
Lets hear it for TEAM effort. (May, 29)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 29)
clarence morgan samuels
re: Trucks (May, 29)