Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Scott Fraser:
re: Trucks were decisive � NOT!

The Soviets may have been able to hold the Germans at bay after 1942 without Lend Lease but I argue that it may not have been able route them out without the support of the explosives, trucks, trains, tanks, etc. I will not go detail here though I refer you to Red Steels website and this one for info on Lend Lease vehicles.

It is nonsense to assert that the trucks supplied to the Red Army were decisive. Certainly, having them made supply and deployment easier, but had they not been available other means would have been found. Like the Wehrmacht, the Red Army depended more on the railroads and the horse. One thing the supply of trucks did do was allow the Soviets to allocate virtually 100% of their manufacturing capacity to producing tanks and aircraft. Similarly, the locomotives and rolling stock supplied made things easier to a degree, but neither of these measures was critical to the Soviet war effort. Quantitatively, by keeping an additional 10% of their production for trucks and locomotives, they could have easily made up these numbers.

Qualitatively, there's no question that the Studebaker truck was a superior vehicle to those available from Russian production, but creature comforts are not that important in such situations, and cargo capacity was similar. As for reliability, parts for the Studebakers was not as easy to find as those for Soviet-produced vehicles, even if they didn't break down as often. It is also worth pointing out that many of these trucks were used as carriers for Katiusha rocket-launchers, which would not have been the case if they were desperately needed for moving men and mat�riel.

As far as quality, the Shermans were well liked according to Guards Colonel Loza, and stood well up to T-34's in Korea.

It is worth pointing out that the Americans named the Sherman "Ronsons". They were very vulnerable to German AT weapons, even the 50mm PaK 38. The M4 Sherman was underarmoured and had a huge silhouette compared ...

>>> 

Sun May 14 18:00:51 2000


 Nick 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 10)
 Tommy Thats right (-) (May, 10)
George Hogg re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 10)
 Nick re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
Scott Fraser re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
Mikhail re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
TS re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
George Hogg re: 8 OUT OF 10!!! (May, 11)
Scott Fraser re: The US Army won the war. (May, 12)
 Max re: The US Army won the war. (May, 12)
 George Hogg re: British wit (May, 13)
 Alex Wood re: British wit (May, 13)
 Zbynio re: British codebrakers ????? (May, 13)
 Alex Wood re: British codebrakers ????? (May, 14)
Kit Hildreth re: British wit (May, 17)
Kit Hildreth re:"The US Army won the war." (May, 17)
Scott Schaffer Whats more.... (May, 12)
Bob Potter In Defense of Stephen Ambrose -- and another thought (May, 13)
 Stephen Brezinski re: Lets look at the war as a whole... (May, 12)
 Nick re: Lets look at the war as a whole... (May, 12)
 Mark Degnan A questions of time... (May, 12)
Zbynio where is victory there is many fathers (-) (May, 12)
 Stephen Brezinski re: Well said.... (May, 13)
 Max Contribution to Victory (May, 13)
Scott Schaffer Trucks (May, 13)
 Max Trucks were not decisive!!!!!  (May, 13)
Bob Potter Boot leather and Rusian Spam (May, 13)
Shveik re: Boot leather and Rusian Spam (May, 14)
 Max Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
Bob re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
 Max re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
George Hogg re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 14)
Bob Wanted to, but couldn�t! (May, 15)
 Anthony Aragon Japs?  (May, 16)
 Bob Oops! (May, 17)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Spam instead of Soldiers!!!! (May, 29)
 Stephen Brezinski re: Trucks were decisive!!!!!  (May, 14)
  • Scott Fraser re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 14)
    TIM re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 15)
     clarence morgan samuels Lets hear it for TEAM effort. (May, 29)
     clarence morgan samuels re: Trucks were decisive � NOT! (May, 29)
  •  clarence morgan samuels re: Trucks (May, 29)

    Records: 43

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.