Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Tero:
Leningrad 41-42 = Stalingrad 42-43 ?

>- Some 30 Soviet infantry divisions would have been wiped out (if we say soviet evacuation/withdrawal is a no-go)

Possibly. But once the town was cut off any and all mass evacuations would have been extremely difficult.

>- Some 10-15 German divisions are freed up

Possbily. But what would their condition been after the brutal street fighting that would have been inevitable. Not to mention the possibility for a need of more troops to actually take the city. It could well have turned into a savage battle like Stalingrad was.

I wonder what would have happened if Hitler had chosen to take this siege approach with Staligrad as well ?

>- The Germans can use the port of Leningrad to supply Army Group North instead of having to rely on the rail roads

Not before they had cleared if of the scuttled Baltic Fleet ships and mines/booby traps. With the big BB's in the harbour entrance and the installations blown the port have been unusable for a year or two.

>- The armaments industry in Leningrad is cnocked out

Yes.

>- Soviet morale receives a blow, as the cradle of the revolution is taken

I'd say it could have strenghtened the resolve. Stalin invoked the patriotic feelings early on and dismissed the soviet or communist rethorics to the background. Churches were reopened etc. so the loss of the cradle would have been surplanted with the loss of the historically significant Russian landmark. The Great Patriotic War could have assumed the ferocity of Russian Jihad more prominently with the loss of Leningrad/St Petersburgh.

>- Half the Finnish army is freed

Yes.

>- The German troops freed can be used to attack the rail line running from Murmansk, as has been pointed out.

Except the German divisions attacking Murmansk up north ran into a brick wall and could not conduct any significant or succesfull offensive operations for the remainder of the war. The direction from Leningrad was defenitively towards Moscow in SE, not NE.

>Perhaps the ...

>>> 

Wed May 10 11:35:35 2000


 Maarten What if leningrad capitulated april 42 ? (May, 4)
 Murph re: What if leningrad capitulated april 42 ? (May, 4)
 Stephen Brezinski re: What if leningrad capitulated april 42 ? (May, 5)
George Hogg re: What if leningrad capitulated april 42 ? (May, 5)
Mikhail re: What if leningrad capitulated april 42 ? (May, 5)
 Max re: What if leningrad capitulated april 42 ? (May, 5)
George Hogg re: Did finland only want its land back? (May, 5)
 Mikhail re: Did finland only want its land back? (May, 6)
 Max re: Did finland only want its land back? (May, 6)
Tomo Moriwaki re: Did finland only want its land back? (May, 7)
Jari Lievonen re: Did finland only want its land back? (May, 8)
Stephen Brezinski re: Though the Soviet Baltic Fleet... (May, 7)
 Anatoly re: What if Russia took Berlin in may 1940 ? (May, 6)
George Hogg re: What if Russia took Berlin in may 1940 ? (May, 6)
 Zbynio re: What if Russia took Berlin in may 1940 ? (May, 8)
Anatoly re: What is comunizm? (May, 17)
 Vinnie O One of my favorite topics (May, 7)
 R.Veenenberg re: What if leningrad capitulated april 42 ? (May, 7)
 Henrik Krog re: What if leningrad capitulated april 42 ? (May, 9)
  • Tero Leningrad 41-42 = Stalingrad 42-43 ? (May, 10)
  • Anatoly re: What if? (May, 11)
     Axl re: What if leningrad capitulated april 42 ? (May, 12)

    Records: 22

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.