Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Tomo Moriwaki:
re: By American taste

I don't think there's anything wrong with thinking the Waffen SS are cool and powerful... (I don't like glamorising ANYTHING that's named after Goering) but they had a lot of problems during the war. It's true that they fought hard and valiantly, but that didn't always make up for the fact that they weren't part of the same organization as the army and therefore couldn't take full advantage of the excellent warfighting experience that the german military's history had to offer. They we're, however, employed in such a fashion as to eventually gain a great deal of experience in combat (as well as getting used to winning) that gave them the opportunity to become very proficient units.
But if I had to choose the greatest armored unit in history it would have to be the DAK... they did a lot of amazing things. It's hard to pin 'great' on a soviet tank unit cause they hardly got the same kinds of opportunities for growth. MANY german units we're heavily pounded but survived, multiple times, and MANY german units were in situations where they had to do the impossible and survive. Russian units seemed to take too many casualties and by the time they we're 'veterans' it was the end of the war and all they did was overrun the germans, so they had no opportunity to pull off some of the longshots that the germans did.

Sun May 7 03:25:05 2000


 Zbynio The No 1 Panzer Division in the World (May, 1)
 Nick re: SS Totenkopf at Kursk!! (May, 2)
Jari Lievonen re: SS Totenkopf at Kursk!! (May, 3)
 Max re: SS Totenkopf at Kursk!! (May, 3)
 Nick re: Death Ride? (May, 3)
Jari Lievonen re: Nothing wrong (May, 3)
 Nick re: Suicide Collisions!?! (May, 3)
Jari Lievonen re: Suicide Collisions!?! (May, 3)
 Max Still a death ride!!! (May, 3)
John Kahl re: Still a death ride!!! (May, 3)
 Max Wildly exaggerated claims!!!! (May, 4)
Juha re: Wildly exaggerated claims!!!! (May, 4)
Jari Lievonen re: Still a death ride!!! (May, 4)
 Amedeo Matteucci Kursk, southern sectors - The numbers (May, 5)
 Zbynio Number-1 Panzer Division (May, 3)
 Zbynio Russians, where are you ?! (May, 4)
 Nick re: Volskiy,s Corps/Armored Group Popov?Or perhaps units of 5TH GDS? (May, 4)
 R.Veenenberg re: Number-1 Panzer Division (May, 7)
John Kahl re: The No 1 Panzer Division in the World (May, 2)
 R.Veenenberg re: The No 1 Panzer Division in the World (May, 3)
j campbell 11th Pz battles on chir river  (May, 4)
 Nick re: Don't forget Panzer Army Africa! (May, 4)
 Zbynio Das Reich (May, 4)
 Zbynio The 11th Panzer Division (May, 4)
 Zbynio Totenkopf SS Panzer Division (May, 4)
 Zbynio Hermann Goering & Lehr Panzer Divisions (May, 4)
 Zbynio Armored Group Popov (May, 4)
 Zbynio German Panzer Division in Africa Corps (May, 4)
 Max 4th Tank Brigade - the very first defeat of panzers (May, 4)
 Zbynio Wow ! (May, 4)
 Juha re: 4th Tank Brigade - the very first defeat of panzers (May, 5)
 Karl Brandel re: 4th Tank Brigade - the very first defeat of panzers (May, 5)
 Max re: 4th Tank Brigade - the very first defeat of panzers (May, 5)
Juha re: 4th Tank Brigade - the very first defeat of panzers (May, 5)
George Hogg re: Das Reich (May, 13)
Hugo Rodrigues re: The No 1 Panzer Division in the World (May, 6)
 Zbynio By American taste (May, 6)
  • Tomo Moriwaki re: By American taste (May, 7)
     Mikhail re: By American taste (May, 7)
    Tomo Moriwaki re: By American taste (May, 9)
     Lee Dowd Radical proposition (Jun, 1)
  • Wiking5th re: The No 1 Panzer Division in the World (May, 13)
     Anthony Aragon re: The No 1 Panzer Division in the World (May, 13)
     Hugo Rodrigues Not me (May, 14)
     Anthony Aragon re: Not me (May, 15)
    George Hogg re: Not me (May, 16)

    Records: 46

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.