Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


morgan samuels:
re: to Morgan Samuels

"To avoid all unnecessary speculations.
According to newly released and formerly classified data Soviets lost around 10,000,000 KIA. Axis powers in the East (Germany, Rumania, Finland, Hungary etc.) lost around 3,500,000. So the ratio is around 3 to 1."

These are just KIA for the Soviet figure and all combat losses for the Axis total, yes?

"Ratios like 10 to 1 or 20 to 1 are fantastic as this would amount to 35 - 70mn Soviets killed."

I did goof. I compared ALL Soviet losses to *German* KIAs. This is not a useful comparison.

Looking at just KIAs paints no less of a skewed picture. Total losses (KIA/WIA/MIA/POW) is a more significant figure as it accounts for all persons not available to fight at the front.

The cumulative Soviet combat losses by February 1945 were 20.5 million including MIAs (those scheduled to be mobalized but trapped in conquered portions of the Soviet Union). By the end of the war another source states that total Soviet losses were 26.4 million including MIAs from rear areas evacuated to Axis countries.

Compare that to all Axis losses and I think one could get a better grip on a meaningfull ratio.
What was the Axis total loss? 6 million?
That would make it 1:4.4

So, taking almost 30 million and dividing by German KIA (1.5 million) you arrive at the useless ratio of 20:1.

I will do some more digging on Axis losses. If you have the hard numbers please post them.

Thu Apr 27 23:52:39 2000


 HERALD About Russian winter (Apr, 10)
Henkster Western History = German History (Apr, 11)
Greg Leon Guerrero re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
George Hogg re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Valera Potapov re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
HERALD re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Valera Potapov re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Trapo re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Nick re: Horses? "General MUD!! (Apr, 11)
Max re: Horses?  (Apr, 11)
Nick re: End of their tether ! (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail Winter (Apr, 11)
HERALD re: End of their tether ! (Apr, 11)
Zbynio Napoleon had the same excuse: Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail winter (Apr, 11)
Robert A. Mosher re: winter (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: winter (Apr, 11)
 Nick re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 11)
BillWilson re: winter (Apr, 14)
 Mikhail re: winter (Apr, 14)
BillWilson re: winter (Apr, 14)
Anatoly re: About Russian winter (Apr, 14)
morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 15)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 15)
 Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 16)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 17)
 Mikhail German Numbers (Apr, 25)
 Max re: German Numbers (Apr, 25)
 Mikhail re: German Numbers (Apr, 26)
 morgan samuels My two centavoes on German Numbers (Apr, 27)
 Mikhail re: My two centavoes on German Numbers (Apr, 28)
 morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 17)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 18)
 morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 19)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 20)
 Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 20)
 morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 21)
 Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 21)
Anatoly re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 17)
 US Sr re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 25)
 US Sr re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 25)
Mike Lotus re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 26)
 morgan samuels re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 26)
 Mikhail re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 26)
 morgan samuels To Mikhail (Apr, 27)
 Max re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 26)
  • morgan samuels re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 27)
     Mikhail re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 28)
     Max re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 28)
     morgan samuels I stand corrected. (Apr, 28)
     Max re: I stand corrected. (Apr, 29)
    Lee Dowd re: I stand corrected. (Jun, 1)
  • Records: 54

    Threads navigation:  prev <<< 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.