Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Scott Fraser:
re:@#$$!...

I think your first point is the most important. Russia is just too big to be conquered from without. There is too much area to try and control, too many cities to garrison, too much distance to try and supply an army. It is a futile endeavour.

As for Napol�on, I think he was his own wrst enemy. He assumed that if he got to Moscow, the Tsar' would sue for peace. It was the "civilized" thing to do, in those days. Instead, Aleksandr refused to play by those rules, or meet Napol�on's expectations. He let Napol�on march deeper and deeper into the country, harassing him, annoying him, and never offering him the decisive battle the French Emperor sought. Even Borodino was anti-climactic � by then much of the French strength had been dissipated, and the Russian army had a better chnce of meeting the invader on even terms.

In my own opinion, the decisive battle of the war was not Borodino but Malojaroslavets, after the retreat from Moscow had begun. Napol�on sought to wheel south, and to return to France along the Kaluga - Mogilev road, with an eye to wintering in Orsha. He planned this knowing that there was very little food or fodder left along the Smolensk - Moscow highway, circumstances made even more severe by the first use of Scorched Earth, and the activities of Partisans. When Kutuzov stopped him from crossing the Luzha, he was forced to retreat along the same route he had entered the country, and his soldiers were doomed. The encounter at the Berezina was almost anti-climactic � of the 540,000 men Napol�on entered Russia with, only 49,000 troops remained, plus another 25,000 stragglers. Perhaps 10,000 men drowned that day on the Berezina, another 40,000 crossed, and of the few who escaped, perhaps 20,000 made it back as far as Vilna.

In 1813, the Duke of Wellington, after hearing about Napol�on's experience with the Grande Arm�e, observed that: "A conqueror is like a cannonball . . . He cannot stop of his own accord. He must go until he runs down or hits something."

Thu Apr 20 08:10:18 2000


Zbynio Anyone interested in the Napoleon's invasion of Russia? (Apr, 18)
Scott Fraser Why Not? (Apr, 18)
Zbynio Invasion of 1812 (Apr, 18)
 Mikhail re: Invasion of 1812 (Apr, 18)
 Mikhail re: Invasion of 1812 (Apr, 18)
 Zbynio re:@#$$!... (Apr, 18)
George Hogg re:Why miss out the Tutonic knights (Apr, 19)
 Mikhail To Zbynio (Apr, 19)
  • Scott Fraser re:@#$$!... (Apr, 20)
  • Records: 9

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.