Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 Mikhail:
To Zbynio

Napoleon's and Hitler's invasion differed in many ways especially politically and militarily.
This is a military forum so politics will not be discussed since it's a much longer topic.

The interesting thing about the war of 1812 was that Napoleon did not really control Russia, he was in Russia. His army could only control places were it was, and since it was not mobile it was a pretty narrow stretch of land going through major Russian cities. Minsk, Smolensk and eventually Moscow. In such circumstances the Grand Armee was stretched to it's limits. Therefore Napoleon was looking for a fight, hoping that Russians will give him a chance. If they didn't he would simply loose because Russian army would always be present in the most vulnerable place plus Napoleon would loose control. It would be even worse than in Spain. Actually Russians realized it too, thy God they had Kutuzov and Barclay making right decisions. Smolensk is not that far from Berezina, few hundred kilometers, however, Napoleon came there with half of his army. Still without getting a battle from the Russian army. To accomplish that he decided to get to Moscow and that's when Borodino happened. However, Kutuzov knew that he was not Napoleon and simply withdrew. Russian army was still not destroyed. Napoleon went to Moscow. To Moscow he came with less than 100,000, out of 500,000 most all streched through Russia. When he came to Moscow there was nothing there to do. No Russian army no population nobody, and it still meant that he did not concur Russia. He decided to go to St. Petersburg but that would mean that he would come there with probably even less troops facing a huge and unscathed Russian army. Plus he was needed in France plus his soldiers were hard to control. Napoleon saw uselessness in his Russian invasion which was going nowhere and he turned back, apparently in the winter with sad consequences for his army. However, if it wasn't winter he would still turn back, and still loose.

Hitler was different. Hitler had different weapons, more troops, a mobilized economy, railroads and better transportation in general, airplanes, and he conducted a total war. He destroyed entire populations or tried to get them on his side. For the walking Grand armee there is no comparison to the mechanized Werchmacht.

Wed Apr 19 18:10:57 2000


Zbynio Anyone interested in the Napoleon's invasion of Russia? (Apr, 18)
Scott Fraser Why Not? (Apr, 18)
Zbynio Invasion of 1812 (Apr, 18)
 Mikhail re: Invasion of 1812 (Apr, 18)
 Mikhail re: Invasion of 1812 (Apr, 18)
 Zbynio re:@#$$!... (Apr, 18)
George Hogg re:Why miss out the Tutonic knights (Apr, 19)
  •  Mikhail To Zbynio (Apr, 19)
  • Scott Fraser re:@#$$!... (Apr, 20)

    Records: 9

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.