ANZAC:
Kultura and Corruption?
Gentlemen (and Ladies?),
Has anyone here read Hans von Luck's 'Panzer Commander' and, if so, what do make of his views on his time in a Russian POW camp and his time in the Soviet Union in general.
In the chapter "Kultura and Corruption: the Russian Mentality", von Luck explains how he genuinely likes and respects the Russians as a people but says that corruption is a natural part of the way Russians organise anything.
For those who have read the book, do you believe his analysis of life in Russia (or more correctly the USSR) is accurate and fair, or do you find his remarks patronising and offensive?
Is corruption a natural consequence of a totalitarian regime or is corruption worse now that Russia is heading towards democracy? Is what the West calls corruption an ingrained part of Russian culture?
Do Russians use the word 'Kultura' in the same context that von Luck used it in Panzer Commander?
If possible, I would like responses from Russians (or people who have been to Russia) who have also read Hans von Luck's book. This is because I may not have explained the context of the book well enough for someone who has not read the book to comment.
I would be interested though in any comment on the last few chapters of the book.
Thanks in Advance,
ANZAC (aka Gavin)
Wed Apr 19 02:00:00 2000
ANZAC
Kultura and Corruption? (Apr, 19)
Mikhail
re: Kultura and Corruption? (Apr, 19)
ANZAC
re: Kultura and Corruption? (Apr, 20)
Alexei
re: Kultura and Corruption? (Apr, 20)
Zbynio
re: Kultura and Corruption? (Apr, 20)
George Hogg
re: Kultura and Corruption? (Apr, 20)