Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


 Mark E. Horan:
re: Why didn't Japan attack USSR in 1941?

Because the defeat suffered by the Japanese Army at the hands of the Russian Army at Nomanhan in July-August 1939 was one of the most crushing defeats suffered in the annals of modern warfare. The Japanes, who considered there troops to be, man for man, the best in the world, and scofferd at the fighting ability of the Russian peasants, had seen there infantry slaughtered by a combined arms army of tanks, planes, modern heavcy artillery, and motorized infantry. The Jpanese had committed a significant portion of there entire Armies tank strength at Nomanhan, two regiments of, at best, mediocre tanks. The Russians had responded with Brigade after Brigade of tanks that, while not individually spectacular (mostly BTs) had proved superior to the Japanes armour in every significant way (armour, gun, speed, engine quality, fuel type, etc.) The Japanese artillery had been outnumbered, out ranged, out weighted, and out performed.

The Japanese Army NEVER seriously considered another war with the Soviets, and were virtually terrified (an rightly so) that one might occur while the bulk of their army was in China.

Had Japan gone to war with Russia in 1941, they would have been crushed again long before the time frame in which the Soviets began pulling the Siberians to European Russia. Optionally, the Russians could simply have fallen back in to the significant fortifications that they had built on the Russian/Manchurian border running north from Vladavostok. The Russians spent the vast bulk of their fort constuction money and concrete in building a significant line in that theatre, something the Japoannese Army was extremely poorly prepared to tacckle given their derth of heavy artillery and reasonably armoured tanks.

Thu Apr 13 03:24:04 2000


 Mikhail Why didn't Japan attack USSR in 1941? (Apr, 12)
Tero re: Why didn't Japan attack USSR in 1941? (Apr, 12)
  •  Mark E. Horan re: Why didn't Japan attack USSR in 1941? (Apr, 13)
     James Quinn Japan's interest / asking for book recommendation (Apr, 13)
    Alexei Luks The Book (Apr, 13)
    Brian George re: The Book (Apr, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Japan's interest / asking for book recommendation (Apr, 15)
    James Quinn re: Japan's interest / asking for book recommendation (Apr, 15)
    Scott Fraser re: Japan's interest / asking for book recommendation (Apr, 16)
    Scott Fraser re: Japan's interest / asking for book recommendation (Apr, 16)
    Lee Dowd re: Japan's interest / asking for book recommendation (May, 25)
    Henkster Nothing to gain (Apr, 13)
     Mikhail re: Nothing to gain (Apr, 13)
    Henkster re: Nothing to gain (Apr, 13)
     Mikhail re: Nothing to gain (Apr, 13)
     Nick re: Japanese Armor (Apr, 13)
     Mikhail re: Japanese Armor (Apr, 14)
     Bob Mackenzie Russian Far East Armour '45 (Apr, 14)
    Nick re: Kholkin Gol? (Apr, 14)
     Tim Emmenegger re: Kholkin Gol? (Apr, 17)
    George Hogg re: Japanese occupation of a time of revolution (Apr, 16)
    Anatoly re: Why didn't Japan attack USSR in 1941? (Apr, 14)
    Lee Dowd re: Why didn't Japan attack USSR in 1941? (May, 24)
  • Records: 23

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.