Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Max:
re: About Russian winter

I must agree with you that failures of planning and extreme self-confidence played a bad trick with Germans. They hoped to finish off Russia before winter, and didn't make any preparations for it. They ended up stranded in front of Moscow with no supplies coming in and fresh Russian troops constantly on the attack. What was decisive, winter or Russian troops - probably both. Germans were overextended anyway and their frontline was bound to be torn someplace. I, however, personally believe that in good weather Germans would have taken Moscow. Whether this would have changed anything in the ultimate outcome of the war is another thing. Success in war is a combination of various factors and all of them play their part. You can't just separate one of them, like cold weather for example, and say that's the one that was decisive. Some German historians say in Ardennes allies were saved likewise by a sudden clearing of the sky which brought their airforce into play, forgetting to mention the tough fight the 101 Airborne and others put up at Bastogne etc.

It must be remembered that the second phase of the Russian offensive at Moscow failed for exactly the same reasons the German did: overestimation of own forces, underestimation of the enemy, winter, breakdown in logistics, tough resistance of the German soldier. The Russians committed the same mistakes as the Germans, bleeding white just like Germans did before them.

Regards

Fri Apr 21 12:33:30 2000


Back to page 

 HERALD About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Henkster Western History = German History (Apr, 11)
Greg Leon Guerrero re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
George Hogg re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Valera Potapov re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
HERALD re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Valera Potapov re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Trapo re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Nick re: Horses? "General MUD!! (Apr, 11)
Max re: Horses?  (Apr, 11)
Nick re: End of their tether ! (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail Winter (Apr, 11)
HERALD re: End of their tether ! (Apr, 11)
Zbynio Napoleon had the same excuse: Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail winter (Apr, 11)
Robert A. Mosher re: winter (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: winter (Apr, 11)
 Nick re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 12)
BillWilson re: winter (Apr, 14)
 Mikhail re: winter (Apr, 14)
BillWilson re: winter (Apr, 14)
Anatoly re: About Russian winter (Apr, 14)
morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 15)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 15)
 Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 16)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 17)
 morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 17)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 18)
 morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 19)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 20)
 Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 20)
 morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 21)
  •  Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 21)
  • Anatoly re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 17)

    Records: 36

    Threads navigation:  189 <<<  188  >>> 187